Post Reply  Post Thread 
Pages (6): « First < Previous 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 Next > Last »
The Neanderthal theory
Author Message
Batman55



Posts: 4,777
Group: Registered
Joined: Feb 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #31
RE: The Neanderthal theory

jewelie Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:

Social imagination is one "type" of imagination, and there is a bridge between imagination and creativity... to some extent.

We live without the convenient NT filter, the "automatic template" that everyone seems to have access to... except for those with AS.

So, those with AS have to find meaning and order manually, and consider everything mindfully...  every thought/item/concept in our world is considered separately, and compared to everything else.  One can see how this "mindful integration" can lead to some very unique interpretations... hence, potential for great creativity.

In summary, I do agree that Aspies can have extraordinary/unusual creativity, and this is one of our greatest strengths.  But at the same time, I think that problems with abstract/symbolic thinking can be considered a kind of "detractor" of creativity in some ways...  and this very problem has stifled my attempts at creative expression, time and time again.


Batman, again, fabulous thoughts.  Thank you for sharing.  Your ideas of "automatic template" and "mindful integration" are very powerful.


If I could find a way to make my thinking process useful in school or anything marketable, it would be nice.  But it doesn't seem like it could possibly happen.

I still think I'm a real, bonafide lemon.  Everyone always talks about getting through school faster here or with honors (AFF)--I have no such stories to report.

Sorry to complain but I don't know what my damn learning problem is.  No one has ever clarified it for me.  And I feel like an idiot, justifiably so.  Aargh!

06-28-2007 08:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quickduck
Unregistered


Post: #32
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Batman55 Wrote:

I still think I'm a real, bonafide lemon.  Everyone always talks about getting through school faster here or with honors (AFF)--I have no such stories to report.

Sorry to complain but I don't know what my damn learning problem is.  No one has ever clarified it for me.  And I feel like an idiot, justifiably so.  Aargh!


Your not a lemon Batman55--or any other kind of brightly coloured citrus fruit.

Although we don’t always agree--your contributions are clever and thoughtful; and often make a great deal more sense than anything I write.

You shouldn’t considered yourself an idiot--you seem a lot more intelligent than most people--with out without honours.

06-28-2007 11:42 PM
Quote this message in a reply
quickduck
Unregistered


Post: #33
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Opps there goes my dyslexia again...

That should have read--'with or without honours'.

06-28-2007 11:45 PM
Quote this message in a reply
alectrum
Unregistered


Post: #34
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Batman55 Wrote:

jewelie Wrote:
Sorry if I'm duplicating here, but I wanted to add that I first heard about this Neanderthal theory in Jen Birch's book, Congratulations!  It's Asperger Syndrome.  I have not read the original link posted here, but I REALLY liked this theory as soon as I read about it in this book.

I also wanted to comment on Batman's creativity post.  It has always irked me that one of the diagnostic criteria for autism includes some badly worded phrase that means we lack creativity.  Every time I read such nonsense I am compelled to begin to list all of the amazing acts of creativity attributed to autistics, from art and literature all the way through to science and math.  Rigid thinking and creativity are not opposites.  Social conformity is the opposite of creativity, if you ask me.  It just reminds me of the "hypocritical ad hominem," accusing the other person of not being able to do what you cannot do yourself, but claim you can, or accusing the other person of doing publicly the very same thing you are doing privately, and getting away with it.  (Sorry no examples come to mind.)


Yes Jewelie, I was referring to a lot of those articles/statements written about AS which (personally) strike me to be somewhat true:  a lack of spontaneous ability in expression of self... the articles I refer to call this "lack of social imagination."  Social imagination is one "type" of imagination, and there is a bridge between imagination and creativity... to some extent.

Furthermore, I feel that a lot of Aspergians have some degree of difficulty with abstract thinking (myself included... reading between the lines in fiction/poetry is very difficult for me.)   To me, this can be interpreted as either a lack of creativity (which those articles/diagnostic criteria mention), or a simple "cognitive roadblock" that NTs aren't familiar with.  To me, still, this is a deficiency.

And yet... Perhaps it is the fact that we have this "abstractification difficulty," paradoxically, that makes us so creative.  We live without the convenient NT filter, the "automatic template" that everyone seems to have access to... except for those with AS.

So, those with AS have to find meaning and order manually, and consider everything mindfully...  every thought/item/concept in our world is considered separately, and compared to everything else.  One can see how this "mindful integration" can lead to some very unique interpretations... hence, potential for great creativity.

In summary, I do agree that Aspies can have extraordinary/unusual creativity, and this is one of our greatest strengths.  But at the same time, I think that problems with abstract/symbolic thinking can be considered a kind of "detractor" of creativity in some ways...  and this very problem has stifled my attempts at creative expression, time and time again.


I design logo's and you can't get any more creative, abstract and symbolic that designing a logo.  Smile  There's quite a lot of aspie's that work in Graphic design, so I don't think that bears out the idea that aspies are lacking in any three of these area's.  I love our infinity symbol.

07-07-2007 10:49 PM
Quote this message in a reply
Batman55



Posts: 4,777
Group: Registered
Joined: Feb 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #35
RE: The Neanderthal theory

alectrum Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:

jewelie Wrote:
Sorry if I'm duplicating here, but I wanted to add that I first heard about this Neanderthal theory in Jen Birch's book, Congratulations!  It's Asperger Syndrome.  I have not read the original link posted here, but I REALLY liked this theory as soon as I read about it in this book.

I also wanted to comment on Batman's creativity post.  It has always irked me that one of the diagnostic criteria for autism includes some badly worded phrase that means we lack creativity.  Every time I read such nonsense I am compelled to begin to list all of the amazing acts of creativity attributed to autistics, from art and literature all the way through to science and math.  Rigid thinking and creativity are not opposites.  Social conformity is the opposite of creativity, if you ask me.  It just reminds me of the "hypocritical ad hominem," accusing the other person of not being able to do what you cannot do yourself, but claim you can, or accusing the other person of doing publicly the very same thing you are doing privately, and getting away with it.  (Sorry no examples come to mind.)


Yes Jewelie, I was referring to a lot of those articles/statements written about AS which (personally) strike me to be somewhat true:  a lack of spontaneous ability in expression of self... the articles I refer to call this "lack of social imagination."  Social imagination is one "type" of imagination, and there is a bridge between imagination and creativity... to some extent.

Furthermore, I feel that a lot of Aspergians have some degree of difficulty with abstract thinking (myself included... reading between the lines in fiction/poetry is very difficult for me.)   To me, this can be interpreted as either a lack of creativity (which those articles/diagnostic criteria mention), or a simple "cognitive roadblock" that NTs aren't familiar with.  To me, still, this is a deficiency.

And yet... Perhaps it is the fact that we have this "abstractification difficulty," paradoxically, that makes us so creative.  We live without the convenient NT filter, the "automatic template" that everyone seems to have access to... except for those with AS.

So, those with AS have to find meaning and order manually, and consider everything mindfully...  every thought/item/concept in our world is considered separately, and compared to everything else.  One can see how this "mindful integration" can lead to some very unique interpretations... hence, potential for great creativity.

In summary, I do agree that Aspies can have extraordinary/unusual creativity, and this is one of our greatest strengths.  But at the same time, I think that problems with abstract/symbolic thinking can be considered a kind of "detractor" of creativity in some ways...  and this very problem has stifled my attempts at creative expression, time and time again.


I design logo's and you can't get any more creative, abstract and symbolic that designing a logo.  Smile  There's quite a lot of aspie's that work in Graphic design, so I don't think that bears out the idea that aspies are lacking in any three of these area's.  I love our infinity symbol.


It was kind of nice to get credit from some folks for writing that message, and kinda rotten to see someone else deflate the good feeling of having written it.

I never said all Aspies lack symbolic/abstract/creative ability... but I know that symbolic thinking is a COMMON problem on the autistic spectrum.  We know that NTs are OFTEN good Symbolic thinkers, their words representative of nonverbal concepts.  We know that AS are OFTEN more literal-minded than NTs.

Well perhaps I did say that "abstractification difficulty" is a fact, and that may have been a poor choice of words on my part.  But then if it's not a fact, how is it so many Aspies have difficulty with fuzzy (dare we say.. abstract?) social interactions?

07-08-2007 07:26 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Batman55



Posts: 4,777
Group: Registered
Joined: Feb 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #36
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Batman55 Wrote:
We know that NTs are OFTEN good Symbolic thinkers, their words representative of nonverbal concepts.  


Maybe I should replace "words" in the above sentence, with body language/facial expression.  Oh stuff it, I just can't get anything right.

07-08-2007 07:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quickduck
Unregistered


Post: #37
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Batman55 Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:
We know that NTs are OFTEN good Symbolic thinkers, their words representative of nonverbal concepts.  


Maybe I should replace "words" in the above sentence, with body language/facial expression.  Oh stuff it, I just can't get anything right.


You shouldn’t be so hard on yourself Batman55. You’re a clever guy who makes intelligent and insightful  comments--I for one have learnt a lot for you. Don’t worry if you post something that you later  regret--I’ve done that countless times--I’m sure many of us have. The important thing is that we contribute what we can and learn from each other. No one has all the answers, but together we can find the truth.

07-08-2007 10:47 PM
Quote this message in a reply
Batman55



Posts: 4,777
Group: Registered
Joined: Feb 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #38
RE: The Neanderthal theory

quickduck Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:
We know that NTs are OFTEN good Symbolic thinkers, their words representative of nonverbal concepts.  


Maybe I should replace "words" in the above sentence, with body language/facial expression.  Oh stuff it, I just can't get anything right.


You shouldn’t be so hard on yourself Batman55. You’re a clever guy who makes intelligent and insightful  comments--I for one have learnt a lot for you. Don’t worry if you post something that you later  regret--I’ve done that countless times--I’m sure many of us have. The important thing is that we contribute what we can and learn from each other. No one has all the answers, but together we can find the truth.


It's just that I thought my earlier post about abstract/symbolic thinking was spot-on, and I had to have someone show me it wasn't.

07-09-2007 07:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quickduck
Unregistered


Post: #39
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Batman55 Wrote:

quickduck Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:
We know that NTs are OFTEN good Symbolic thinkers, their words representative of nonverbal concepts.  


Maybe I should replace "words" in the above sentence, with body language/facial expression.  Oh stuff it, I just can't get anything right.


You shouldn’t be so hard on yourself Batman55. You’re a clever guy who makes intelligent and insightful  comments--I for one have learnt a lot for you. Don’t worry if you post something that you later  regret--I’ve done that countless times--I’m sure many of us have. The important thing is that we contribute what we can and learn from each other. No one has all the answers, but together we can find the truth.


It's just that I thought my earlier post about abstract/symbolic thinking was spot-on, and I had to have someone show me it wasn't.


I think your comments concerning abstract/symbolic thinking are excellent--‘spot on' in fact. I really enjoy reading your posts; they make me see things in a whole new way--from a different angle--make me question my assertions. You have a gift for seeing things other people miss.

Because you see things differently, doesn’t mean you see them wrongly.

07-11-2007 01:35 AM
Quote this message in a reply
Shrek



Posts: 9,828
Group: Registered
Joined: Apr 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #40
RE: The Neanderthal theory

I think I need to reiterate, find your gifts and play them up for decades.

I said decades.  I am 37.

My gifts are predominantly academic, and my mother (and also father, but less so) strenuously encouraged my academic and social development through the end of college and she supported my grad school strategy too.  She appropriated household money for several collections of books for children (american history, world history, creativity), other things like geographic puzzle maps of USA, first a Texas Instruments and then an IBM PCjr, and my college education, insisting that I live on campus when Dad thought it was a waste of money.

Even in the absence of both parents I buy and read books and magazines, watch digital cable (Comcast channels over 100, National Geographic Channel, Science Channel, Discovery Times Channel, Military Channel, History International, BBC America, to say nothing of Discovery Channel, Learning Channel, History Channel, Animal Planet, Discovery Health Channel, and three local PBS affiliates.)

Including kindergarten, over 20 years of classroom time, not including the self-motivated continuing education.

If I seem smart, it is not for anyone to feel bad about.  God gives what He gives.  And I had a mother that pushed me so hard in school I came to push myself hard too, and remain curious.


Try me on FaceBook https://www.facebook.com/#!/christopher.marsh3

You may need to friend me (it is restricted so employers can't see it)
07-11-2007 07:00 AM
Visit this users website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Batman55



Posts: 4,777
Group: Registered
Joined: Feb 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #41
RE: The Neanderthal theory

I'm just a very jealous person.  What can I do about it.

07-11-2007 07:27 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Shrek



Posts: 9,828
Group: Registered
Joined: Apr 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #42
RE: The Neanderthal theory

I think a better word for jealous is envious, or covetous, in that context.

What are your gifts?  They could be anything.

1.  Knowledge
2.  Creativity


Try me on FaceBook https://www.facebook.com/#!/christopher.marsh3

You may need to friend me (it is restricted so employers can't see it)
07-11-2007 05:01 PM
Visit this users website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Shrek



Posts: 9,828
Group: Registered
Joined: Apr 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #43
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Accidental submission, sorry

1.  Knowledge
    any subject
2.  Creativity
   a. music
   b. art
    (1) sculpture
    (2) painting
3. Character
   a. perseverance
   b. honesty
   c. generosity
   d. compassion
   e. tolerance
   f. gentleness
4. rare for us, but possibly athletic ability, sports ability, or the ability to exercise harder than the other folks in the gym
5. a body other adults find attractive (usually, but not always limited to, the alternate gender, never say opposite sex), look, I don't attract women by looks, today, (my BMI is still over 42, medical diagnosis of morbid obesity, BMI > 40, obesity is BMI > 30 and overweight is BMI > 25)  but sometimes I interest them by having knowledge in a subject they are interested in and talk about.
6. a career and related knowledge
7. a relationship

Wikipedia.org describes falling upward as romantic attraction based on the other's superior qualities.  I understand.  Sociable and attractive women of any age get my attention.  It is almost as if they can create the perception they want you to have of them (happy, got it all together, productive, no difficulty with dates, etc.).  

Wikipedia also described nerds (allegation since retracted) last March as frequently depicted in the popular culture as lovelorn, seeking women above their "status", and also described the popular culture making sport (fun) of nerds who confidently try the same.

Most of my difficulty ended right there when I read that.

We can probably become better looking, esp. with weight loss, and painfully, we will become more sociable.


Try me on FaceBook https://www.facebook.com/#!/christopher.marsh3

You may need to friend me (it is restricted so employers can't see it)
07-11-2007 05:13 PM
Visit this users website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Alison



Posts: 8,670
Group: Registered
Joined: Jun 2005
Status: Online
Post: #44
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Guesswho, is that your picture at the bottom of your email?  

I've always thought you looked very nice: the sort of "gentle" face you rarely see on NTs, a certain childlike enthusiasm which appears to be common amongst those of us AS who haven't been too badly disillusioned by the world, or who have managed to rise above it despite everything.  

Maybe that's another thing to add to your list: we have the perseverance to survive and prosper despite being disregarded by the NTs at best or treated as something somehow sub-human at worst.

BTW, I've always thought the self-portraits by Da Vinci had the same quality.  I'm sure he was "one of us".  

Alison


To be ruled by tradition just means that you're letting yourself be outvoted by the dead.
-----------
Check out my DeviantArt gallery for my stories, art and photography:
http://fayzbub.deviantart.com/
I'd love to see you there!
07-12-2007 12:30 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Alison



Posts: 8,670
Group: Registered
Joined: Jun 2005
Status: Online
Post: #45
RE: The Neanderthal theory

Oops, I see you've got perseverance listed!  Sorry, I missed that, I'm in a hurry to start a brand-new job (I got made redundant three weeks ago, but thanks to good qualifications and being able to act "passably normie" I start a new job today.  And I'm stimming by wasting time here on the internet rather than getting all my details (bank account number, police check, superannuation details and tax file number, etc) ready!
Wish me luck!
Alison


Alison Wrote:
Maybe that's another thing to add to your list: we have the perseverance to survive and prosper despite being disregarded by the NTs at best or treated as something somehow sub-human at worst.

BTW, I've always thought the self-portraits by Da Vinci had the same quality.  I'm sure he was "one of us".  

Alison


To be ruled by tradition just means that you're letting yourself be outvoted by the dead.
-----------
Check out my DeviantArt gallery for my stories, art and photography:
http://fayzbub.deviantart.com/
I'd love to see you there!
07-12-2007 12:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Pages (6): « First < Previous 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 Next > Last »
Post Reply  Post Thread 

View a Printable Version
Send this Thread to a Friend
Subscribe to this Thread | Add Thread to Favorites

Forum Jump: