A sweet natured Muslim, Hindu, Atheist, Buddhist or what have you, can lead a decent life and be kind and exhibits all the behaviours sought after by God.....except one. They do not worhip God.
Their punishment? eternal damnation and fire and torment for eternity.
A death row killer/rapist. In his years of incarceration "finds" God and accepts him......and is "saved"
The act of salvation gets him an audience and ticket into heaven.
God is not compassionate nor moral by this reading and worse the lynchpin of the faith is not your moral credibility but your unquestioning servitute to the idea of him and your want to blindly accept and worship him aand denouncing all other Gods.
The morality is an add-on at best. Your servitude is what is required. That is not moral.