Thread Closed  Post Thread 
Pages (26): « First < Previous 18 19 20 21 [22] 23 24 25 26 Next > Last »
Why do people hate us?
Author Message
zoey



Posts: 868
Group: Registered
Joined: May 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #316
RE: Why do people hate us?

Johanna Wrote:

Ethel Wrote:
Yes, and I have a friend with an autistic kid, and she reports that since she and he started a gluten free diet they've both been a lot healthier, and her lad's a more comfortable, happier, 'functional' kid.  Whether he'd still have food intolerances if he wasn't autistic really is a moot point, it doesn't change the fact that at least one autistic person is healthier on a GF/CF diet.

The point I'm trying to make is that making grand sweeping statements like "GF/CF diets are stupid!" is not especially helpful.


I did not mean to say that all GF/CF diets are stupid. I just hate it that quacks use them to treat any form of autism, especially if there is no proof of the autistic having food intolerances. I thank you, Ethel, for pointing out my mistake.

07-21-2008 06:33 AM
Find all posts by this user
zoey



Posts: 868
Group: Registered
Joined: May 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #317
RE: Why do people hate us?

zoey Wrote:

Johanna Wrote:

Ethel Wrote:
Yes, and I have a friend with an autistic kid, and she reports that since she and he started a gluten free diet they've both been a lot healthier, and her lad's a more comfortable, happier, 'functional' kid.  Whether he'd still have food intolerances if he wasn't autistic really is a moot point, it doesn't change the fact that at least one autistic person is healthier on a GF/CF diet.

The point I'm trying to make is that making grand sweeping statements like "GF/CF diets are stupid!" is not especially helpful.


I did not mean to say that all GF/CF diets are stupid. I just hate it that quacks use them to treat any form of autism, especially if there is no proof of the autistic having food intolerances. I thank you, Ethel, for pointing out my mistake.


  It is surprising that someone with AS would make a blanket scientific about the biochemical aspects of AS without doing the research first or, if that's not doable to have someone else research it and explain it to them.  Autism is intrinsically linked with digestive issues.  Brain chemistry and digestion are intrinsically linked.  To discount the science because unethical people are using it in connection with their cause is using bias.  It's putting a slant on things in the same way that the unethical group is.

07-21-2008 06:53 AM
Find all posts by this user
Ethel
Unregistered


Post: #318
RE: Why do people hate us?

Thank you, Zoey - I thought I'd read something to that affect, but because I can never remember *where* I read these things, I didn't want to talk about it if I couldn't back it up.

07-21-2008 08:01 AM
Tigger_the_Wing
Activist
***


Posts: 3,692
Group: Activists
Joined: Jul 2006
Status: Offline
Post: #319
RE: Why do people hate us?

I'm on a gluten-free diet because eating anything with gluten in it causes intense gut pain within twenty minutes that lasts for hours, followed by weeks of diarrhœa.

I also try to avoid milk products within an hour or so of bedtime or I will be snoring all night from allergic rhinitis. But having an otherwise permanently stuffy nose is something I am prepared to tolerate as milk products are by far the simplest source of calcium (I am far more afraid of osteoporosis than a blocked nose) and the vast majority of GF foods contain cows' milk products.

Now, I can imagine that me-on-gluten, because I am sick and in pain, looks far more autistic than me-on-the-GF-diet but that doesn't mean that my autism is 'cured' by the diet, just that I have more energy to cope with the stresses of 'normal' life.

When I am ill, I just cannot be bothered with the outside world and I withdraw just the way a sick animal does.

Unfortunately, all the articles I have found that posit a connection between gluten enteropathy and brain chemical (im)balance come from fringe sites, usually associated with some product or other. If anyone has a link to a reputable site that mentions anything about gluten and the brain, I would be very interested...


Tigger the Pokégran says:
Life IS a bed of roses - I just keep lying on the thorns!
07-21-2008 09:04 AM
Visit this users website Find all posts by this user
Johanna



Posts: 442
Group: Registered
Joined: Jul 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #320
RE: Why do people hate us?

zoey Wrote:
  It is surprising that someone with AS would make a blanket scientific about the biochemical aspects of AS without doing the research first or, if that's not doable to have someone else research it and explain it to them.  Autism is intrinsically linked with digestive issues.  Brain chemistry and digestion are intrinsically linked.  To discount the science because unethical people are using it in connection with their cause is using bias.  It's putting a slant on things in the same way that the unethical group is.


I did some research on GF/CF diets and while it may or may not help with behavior, they can help with digestive problems. I'm sorry for speaking out against GF/CF diets. However, that thing about autism being intrinsically liked to digestion I cannot believe. Me and five of my siblings are autistic, none of us are on GF/CF diets, and we're all fine. This is because, according to the doctors, they haven't found any sign of food intolerances in our bodies. While I won't make blanket statements, I stand firm on this statement: autistic people don't always have digestive problems, but if they get along better by avoiding certain foods, that's fine.


Gracie needs help with a serious issue. And quickly! Click here for details. I've got a minor problem that needs solving before I start high school. Please click here for details and maybe even give me some feedback.
My post count is the one listed below my name here + 77
07-21-2008 02:42 PM
Find all posts by this user
Joker



Posts: 386
Group: Registered
Joined: Nov 2007
Status: Offline
Post: #321
RE: Why do people hate us?

I don't really apply to any kinds of diets. That being said though, I dislike eating any and all seafoods. They really don't agree with my guts.

Man, this thread has come a long way; From a question about why people hate us, to dietary discussion.
I think I much prefer this topic over the original topic. Smile

07-21-2008 08:21 PM
Find all posts by this user
Johanna



Posts: 442
Group: Registered
Joined: Jul 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #322
RE: Why do people hate us?

Okay, Joker, if it makes you feel better, I'll do my best to switch it to the original topic. I hate that people look at autism as a disease to be cured. It hurts my feelings a lot because I like the way I am and I do not think I am diseased. It sickens me that people try to cure autism through chelation and a whole bunch of other things.


Gracie needs help with a serious issue. And quickly! Click here for details. I've got a minor problem that needs solving before I start high school. Please click here for details and maybe even give me some feedback.
My post count is the one listed below my name here + 77
07-21-2008 09:57 PM
Find all posts by this user
Tigger_the_Left_Wing



Posts: 44
Group: Registered
Joined: Jan 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #323
RE: Why do people hate us?

Joker Wrote:
Man, this thread has come a long way; From a question about why people hate us, to dietary discussion.
I think I much prefer this topic over the original topic. Smile


(My emphasis)

Johanna Wrote:
Okay, Joker, if it makes you feel better, I'll do my best to switch it to the original topic. I hate that people look at autism as a disease to be cured. It hurts my feelings a lot because I like the way I am and I do not think I am diseased. It sickens me that people try to cure autism through chelation and a whole bunch of other things.


Either you didn't read what Joker wrote, or you deliberately did the opposite! Rolleyes


Infecting the site since January 28th
07-21-2008 10:11 PM
Find all posts by this user
Ethel
Unregistered


Post: #324
RE: Why do people hate us?

But she's not actually talking to us, it's a speech made for the benefit of all the people who are goingto find this thread through google.  Smile

07-21-2008 10:39 PM
Johanna



Posts: 442
Group: Registered
Joined: Jul 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #325
RE: Why do people hate us?

Actually, I gave up speaking to speaking to people finding this page through Google a while ago. Unfortunately, putting someone on Ignore doesn't mean that you cannot see the subject's posts. This means that the person cannot flame you through PM, but s/he can do it in posts. *sighs*


Gracie needs help with a serious issue. And quickly! Click here for details. I've got a minor problem that needs solving before I start high school. Please click here for details and maybe even give me some feedback.
My post count is the one listed below my name here + 77
07-22-2008 12:32 AM
Find all posts by this user
Ethel
Unregistered


Post: #326
RE: Why do people hate us?

Personal attacks reported to moderator.

07-22-2008 05:58 AM
zoey



Posts: 868
Group: Registered
Joined: May 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #327
RE: Why do people hate us?

Johanna Wrote:

zoey Wrote:
  It is surprising that someone with AS would make a blanket scientific about the biochemical aspects of AS without doing the research first or, if that's not doable to have someone else research it and explain it to them.  Autism is intrinsically linked with digestive issues.  Brain chemistry and digestion are intrinsically linked.  To discount the science because unethical people are using it in connection with their cause is using bias.  It's putting a slant on things in the same way that the unethical group is.


I did some research on GF/CF diets and while it may or may not help with behavior, they can help with digestive problems. I'm sorry for speaking out against GF/CF diets. However, that thing about autism being intrinsically liked to digestion I cannot believe. Me and five of my siblings are autistic, none of us are on GF/CF diets, and we're all fine. This is because, according to the doctors, they haven't found any sign of food intolerances in our bodies. While I won't make blanket statements, I stand firm on this statement: autistic people don't always have digestive problems, but if they get along better by avoiding certain foods, that's fine.



    When you say you did some research, that is not going to be enough.  It is a hugely complicated subject.  Austistics do not have the amount of food enzyme production non-autistics have.   The lack of enzyme is a genetic component of being autistic.  Neurotransmitters and brain chemical hormones are countless other body functions are created and regulated through processes that start with the breakdown of food by enzymes.    

    Try to let go of the curebie wheat dairy diet concept.  It was just a theory a few years ago, never proven.  That diet can help autistic people sometimes, but it is not a direct connection, it just helps other things that help other things that eventually help with the brain chemicals. It is very very complicated and pretty boring unless you are an older aspie and have to deal with it because the little amount of enzyme production you had reduces to pretty much nothing and you have no choice but to learn about it just to get through your life.

07-22-2008 06:05 AM
Find all posts by this user
Alias Pseudonym



Posts: 880
Group: Registered
Joined: Apr 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #328
RE: Why do people hate us?

Ethel Wrote:
I thought I'd read something to that affect...


...effect...

Sorry.

I dunno, I'm an aspie and my digestive system works quite admirably.


07-22-2008 07:01 AM
Find all posts by this user
Johanna



Posts: 442
Group: Registered
Joined: Jul 2008
Status: Offline
Post: #329
RE: Why do people hate us?

Ethel Wrote:
Personal attacks reported to moderator.


About that, I have been trying not to attack you and would very much like this flame war to end because I don't like being rude and I'm sure both of us are worn out.


Gracie needs help with a serious issue. And quickly! Click here for details. I've got a minor problem that needs solving before I start high school. Please click here for details and maybe even give me some feedback.
My post count is the one listed below my name here + 77
07-22-2008 05:24 PM
Find all posts by this user
Ethel
Unregistered


Post: #330
RE: Why do people hate us?

Johanna, it's very simple.  If you don't want to be rude, don't be.  If you don't want to pick fights, don't.  If you want to play nicely with the other members, do so.

But if you DO insult other members, call them names, question their sanity, tell them they sound like they're incoherent from chemotherapy, or that they need psychological help because their belifs differ from yours, do not expect the rest of us to lie down and take it passively.  I am not a doormat, and having a random stranger type words at me for 48 hours is not remotely going to "wear me out".

07-23-2008 06:45 AM
Thread Closed  Post Thread 

View a Printable Version
Send this Thread to a Friend
Subscribe to this Thread | Add Thread to Favorites

Forum Jump: