Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: autistics vrs aspergers
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Overall, why should there be a "vs" competition (if only stated) between Aspergers and other autistic disorders?  We should all be on the same page here.

silky Wrote:

silky Wrote:

seven Wrote:
aspies understand auties about as well as NTs understand aspies.

everyone talks about how NTs dont understand them, what about how you dont understand aspies?

no one ever seems to notice that.


Are you saying that LFAs best understand other LFAs in a room together?  I'm just curious



Oh, nevermind. I now see where you wrote that. Thank you Smile


Maybe LFA's understand themselves better than anyone else.  Sometimes they just can not communicate it.  It is just about communication, not better or worse or smarter or more deserving to live (and not be aborted).

seven Wrote:

aspies talk about how they are autistic, and claim they understand me, untill i have a "quiet day" or "off day" or if i get stressed or upset and start speaking oddly. or they get mad at the way i speak as if its on perpus.

there are a few major differences betwen aspies and auties, mainly verbal, i cannot express myself verbally often correctly, and all my senteses may be taken SO literally by some aspies and when i explain myself tehy jsut repeat what i said first over and over, refusing to acknoledge my meaning over my exact words. and if i get too stressed i speak very horridly, and end up feeling like a helpless 5 year old, and the mroe i try to speak when upset, the more irritated everyone around me gets, and the more frantic i get.

some aspies i can USUALLY communicate with specifically visual-spcial aspies, but even then its not all the time and they easilly misunderstand me, but some are insufferable and just dont even try.

aspies think im a total weirdo usually, becuase im "more extreme" on teh spectrum than them obviously.


I don't know. That kind of thing (the bolded stuff) happens to me whenever I get stressed, emotional, or overstimulated. Which is not infrequently. I have a wide vocabulary and can be quite articulate, but verbal fluency is really more the exception than the rule for me. Sometimes I repeat the same few sentences, with maybe slight structural variations, over and over for two or three minutes (which might not sound like a long time, but when everyone in the room has their attention turned to you, waiting for you to finally make your point, it seems years). Sometimes I start laughing hysterically mid-sentence, sometimes I talk so fast and at such a low volume and with such poor diction that not even my mother could tell what the hell I'm trying to say. Half the time, I don't even know I'm doing these things. The other half, I'm excruciatingly aware but can't force myself to speak normally. Usually I just give up and shut up for a couple hours till I'm more collected.

My official diagnosis (well, the one of them that's relevant here) is Asperger's Syndrome.

What I'm trying to say here is, it's not so clear-cut as "trouble with spoken language=Kanner's autism". Lots of aspies-- heck, lots of NTs-- have problems talking and/or communicating. Speech impediments, learning disabilities, selective mutism, and the list goes on. It's hardly unique to Kanner's, or even the autism spectrum in general. And within the spectrum, there can be a lot of blurring. It's not always easy to place someone as eccentric normal, AS, high functioning, middle functioning, low functioning, whatever. You said that there are hundreds of differences between Kannerites and aspies, but there are hundreds of differences between any two people on the spectrum. Any two people, period, actually. Because everybody has her own mind, there are bound to be some misunderstandings and arguments among groups of interacting human beings. You are generalizing wildly, both in your assumption that functioning can be reliably determined solely by conversational skills and also in your statement that "aspies think I'm a total weirdo, because I'm more extreme on the spectrum than them, obviously". I mean, maybe some aspies think that, but that doesn't mean we all do. I'm not going to claim I understand you, because I don't, but I'm very willing to listen to your point of view. I would do the same if I met you in real life. No matter how clumsily you expressed yourself.

Labels, labels, labels. This is what I don't like about having diagnosises to begin with. Everyone says, "Oh, you're X! I know what Xs are like. Xs are all the same." or else it's, "You can't be X, because you don't fit my preconcieved notions about Xs. I don't believe you." or "You're an X and I'm a Y. By default, we're too different to ever get along, so just forget about it." Rolleyes

seven: i understand what you're trying to say Smile and i think we should try to have more unity between HFA and LFA to make sure no one is left out and completely mis-understood.

seven Wrote:
brace yourself, becuase i major trouble putting thoughts into words on days like today. heres my attempt to explain.

aspies talk about how they are autistic, and claim they understand me, untill i have a "quiet day" or "off day" or if i get stressed or upset and start speaking oddly. or they get mad at the way i speak as if its on perpus.

there are a few major differences betwen aspies and auties, mainly verbal, i cannot express myself verbally often correctly, and all my senteses may be taken SO literally by some aspies and when i explain myself tehy jsut repeat what i said first over and over, refusing to acknoledge my meaning over my exact words. and if i get too stressed i speak very horridly, and end up feeling like a helpless 5 year old, and the mroe i try to speak when upset, the more irritated everyone around me gets, and the more frantic i get.

some aspies i can USUALLY communicate with specifically visual-spcial aspies, but even then its not all the time and they easilly misunderstand me, but some are insufferable and just dont even try.

aspies think im a total weirdo usually, becuase im "more extreme" on teh spectrum than them obviously.

its the exact same thing with NTs and aspies, and im stating to get that this is an ASPIE website and im certainly not an aspie.

it ends up feeling like like im a different species not only form NTs, but from aspies too. eberywhere i go. on here, elsewhere online, in real life, everywhere at all. i do understand other auties perfectly and vice versa, just aspies are so different and they dont even realize it usually.


This makes me think that I am autistic in the classical sense, not aspie, because  this particular thing also happens to me all the time, and it is so frustrating.

nyanchan Wrote:
I still believe that everyone has valuable experience to contribute. I cannot say what other people's experience is because that is other people. Not me.

As for the "no dating Aspies" rule, it's kind of limiting, isn't it?

It's like, maybe you have a series of relationships.

First, you have a bad experience with an Aspie so you stop dating aspies.

Second, you have a bad experience with a blonde person, so you stop dating blonde people.

Third, you have a bad experience with a big person, so you stop dating big people

Fourth, you have a bad experience with a small person, so you stop dating small people.

Before you know it, the only people you have left to date are size 14 brunettes, nobody who comes from Asia, Australia or anywhere in Western Europe. No aspies, goths, bogans, university students, or anyone who likes sports or movies. You won't date people from cities, you won't date people from farms, and you won't date people with blue eyes or freckles. You won't date people with pets and you won't date anyone who goes running every morning...

...And the next thing you know, the only possible dating partner is a rather lonely looking sheep...

Some people are that fussy and then I suppose they would say the sheep was "too fluffy" or something. Smile

Ziyaret Wrote:
One thing that does appear to be true-and which I have always thought of as the defining feature of autism-is the Lack of interest in social interaction and in other people in general. But if you "dont have the time to elaborate" than how can you justify your arguments? There seems to be an objection amonst some of you here to my categorizing autism and asperger syndrome rather than just lumping them all together in the nebuluous group of [i]autistic spectral disorders[i/].

Ziyaret, my understanding is that Aspergers' people tend to wish for more social interaction than HFA but are often not sure how to fill that need. They know all too well they are "different" but not how to get accepted.

HFA people might also want some social interaction but tend to be more happy with their own company.

NB: if this is a mistaken view, I will listen to reasonable refutations.

tenaciouscj Wrote:
Some people are that fussy and then I suppose they would say the sheep was "too fluffy" or something. Smile


Massive, major, side-splitting laugh out loud!!! Big GrinBig GrinBig Grin

tenaciouscj Wrote:
Ziyaret, my understanding is that Aspergers' people tend to wish for more social interaction than HFA but are often not sure how to fill that need. They know all too well they are "different" but not how to get accepted.

HFA people might also want some social interaction but tend to be more happy with their own company.

NB: if this is a mistaken view, I will listen to reasonable refutations.


I'm aspie but always been happier with my own company. What's in "society" that's so worth having?

The only reason that I cared about having friends as a kid was so that Mum would stop nagging me.

That's my two bits, anyway...

Batman55 Wrote:

Noetic Wrote:

seven Wrote:
maybe hes not mature, but hes also not obnoxious, there is a large difference between the two. the thing about immature guys is that they learn and grow, while obnoxious guys.. dont. Wink


That's an excellent point! Smile


The narcissistic jocks I knew from high school were very "masculine" and seen as "mature" and yet they refused to let down their ego for even one second.  All the girls were interested in them, and yet I had hardly ever observed more obnoxious, arrogant individuals than them.  Putting everyone seen as "inferior" down, to help themselves feel "superior."

Well, you know what? These guys acted far more immaturely than most. A few might have come to their senses later on but I wouldn't be surprised if, 10 years or so later, others are still ego-maniac.

A person with good self-confidence doesn't feel the need to belittle and shame others.

Yeah, I get that too. It has caused no end of misunderstandings.
There's also blue and orange and yellow and red and purple and green and thousands of other wonderful colours.
Thanks. Smile
Er, I got rather baffled by that representation too, but if I studied it long enough I could probably make sense of it.
Me neither.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Reference URL's