Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Debate with a curebie
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.

GreenLion Wrote:
I find it interesting and dismaying that until Bethduckie and Briana (who are apparently not themselves autistic) no one had spoken out with the slightest hint of sympathy, even in passing, for what parents of autistic children go through.  No one, from what was written, was moved in the slightest by their heartfelt and real emotion.

All the comments went from being bizarre ("this is part of a deliberate plot to kill all autistic people") to merely being totally self-referential and self-absorbed ("this real footage of autistic behavior makes me look bad").

I hate to sound provocative, but it somewhat reminds me of the apparently greater on average difficulty autistic children have in forming emotional attachments and empathy for others (even their own parents), and exhibiting or perhaps even feeling concern for anything apart from their own interests, needs, and demands.


What a load of bunk.  Hardly anybody in the media ever talks about what it must be like to be called a disease, worthless, to be looked down on for nothing you have any control over.  All of the mothers in the video are thinking only of themselves.  They ask for no sympathy for their children, the only people they want to change are the ones who call them bad mothers.  They say nothing of the murderers.  Nothing about abusers.  Nothing about bullies.  "Have some compassion for our selfish asses, we gave birth to monsters."  

They know nothing about compassion, and obviously neither do you.

Quote:
I hate to sound provocative, but it somewhat reminds me of the apparently greater on average difficulty autistic children have in forming emotional attachments and empathy for others (even their own parents), and exhibiting or perhaps even feeling concern for anything apart from their own interests, needs, and demands.


maybe becuase the autistic children are constabally being bullied by every other kid in the area, and sometimes abused by their parents that desire an nt child.  that was how i was when i was younger, and i was kinda irrabtle for a bit.  but now, i can easily form attachements to my friends, and some attachements to people on the net i never met, so to say that autistics cannot form emotional attachements is false.  i have had comments from nt's saying i form emotnal attachements very quickly.  all i needed was a postive envorment where people were supportive of me instead of putting me down.  my parents were always there for me and accepted me who i am and didn't want me to become nt.  and they know i love them.

as an autistic, i feel that autistics need a postive support group that accepts them who they are instead of trying to change them.  my friends all think of me as unqinge and fun and hope i never change.  parents need to understand that too, and then you will see that many autsistcs start making those emotional attachements very easliy.  i just wished i had some good friends earlier.

and no, i don't form bonds with people that have an adgenda to get rid of me...that's just sick.  i shouldn't have to say sorry to the guy who wants me gone.

GreenLion Wrote:
That seems like part of the pattern I cited earlier of putting words in my mouth that I did not say. I didn't call anyone a genetic abnormality; regardless of its accuracy, that's a harsh-sounding label with a perjorative connotation and is therefore unnecessarily rude.  However, it's well-established that autism is associated with genetic abnormality.

You and others who are taking offense at some of my statements and opinions need to distinguish between what I am saying about autism versus what I am saying about people with autism.  You are not autism.  You are a person with autism.

Saying that I would like to end autism doesn't mean I want to "get rid" of people with autism.  Saying that autism imposes a severe cost on a family is to blame the AUTISM, not the PEOPLE with autism.


in short, you are calling us defectives that need autism removed.  autism is part of who we are, like blackness is part of what black people are.

we can also go and say that nt is a disease that afflicts people.  ntism has a high cost of socitey, didn't you know?  autism is not something that afflicts us and prevents us from being the best we can be.

we didn't say we are autism, but autism is part of the core.  you remove that, and we aren't us anymore.  contdaity to many lies, we are not trapped in some monstorus cages pleading to get out.

GreenLion Wrote:

bravesj858 Wrote:
in short, you are calling us defectives that need autism removed.


I support a cure for autism.  Calling someone "defective" implies a denial of his humanity or of his innate worth.  It's much easier to reject my ideas if you distort them into inflammatory ways, isn't it?  Easier to demonize me then listen to me.


so you're calling us monsters again...i see.

GreenLion Wrote:

bravesj858 Wrote:
we can also go and say that nt is a disease that afflicts people.  ntism has a high cost of socitey, didn't you know?


That's a ludicrous idea.  (Note to the perpetually aggrieved and thin-skinned: I am NOT dismissing all autistics' ideas or all autistics.  I'm calling a specific ludicous idea ludicrous).

Autism is a disorder (and often a severely debilitating one); normality, by definition, is not.

It may be seem compelling and comforting to latch onto an equating of autism and normality, to pretend that autism and normality are equivalent, like chocolate and strawberry, but it is a false comfort.  

What's more, it's unnecessary.  All human beings are worthy of respect as such.

Finally, doing so implies a refusal to face unpleasant facts about real life and the real world.  But facing such things is a necessary element of adulthood and self-acceptance.


when you get to normal, we get mediocrity.  my belife has been everyone is diffrent, and not every diffrence from the precived normal is a defect.  and you say that autism is often severly disabliing.  i think the majority of autistics would not consider themselves severley disabled.  there are also plenty of non autistic people that are disabled.  i guess they are all autistic.

GreenLion Wrote:
In my view, it's self-evident that it does afflict those who have it, and that if it doesn't prevent them from being the best that they can, it presents substantial and serious obstacles in their way that would otherwise not be there, in addition to all the other obstacles that everyone else has to deal with.


so it's automactially a harder life for us to do anything at all...excuse me.  i can do things alot quicker and alot better than many nt's, and again, you are poprting that we are dumb.

GreenLion Wrote:

bravesj858 Wrote:
we didn't say we are autism, but autism is part of the core.  you remove that, and we aren't us anymore.  contdaity to many lies, we are not trapped in some monstorus cages pleading to get out.


The explosive frustration often exhibited by autistic children struggling to communicate their needs to ordinary people suggests otherwise.


is that talking only?  so all of a sudden if we don't talk we don't communicate?  the struglle alot of times is people to understand us, and sometimes don't want to understand us unless we communicate like they do.

lets say you were in japan.  americans would have a struggle to comminutate to the oridnary people there.  and all children do struggle to communcate, it's just longer for autistic people, and simular to the culture secario.

here's my thoughts.  would i force you to become autistic (if that were possible)?  no.  autism is normal for us, we don't know how to be nt, and we here at aff say that autism is normal for us, and not something that afflicts us.  so i think it would be hypocrital for you to say that we should become nt.  after all, we are all equal human beings here.

we are not trying to say that autistics present diffrent challenges, but you are saying that life is harder and worse for us becuase we are autistic.  all we want is respect.

Amy Wrote:
The explosive frustration often exhibited by autistic children struggling to communicate their needs to ordinary people suggests otherwise.

Dear oh dear, you have fundamentally failed to realise that it's because an autistic would be talking to someone like you, that people like you make communication hard for autistics, with your subtle and unsubtle put downs, dismissals, and continual complaints.
If any of us show annoyance it will be then stated by you 'well autistics have emotional outbursts' etc.

You would not accept that you are causing it, or bear any responsibilty in it.


well said.  i also like to add that nt's like this one tend to also have emontal outbursts and shouldn't try to ocarize us becuase we're autistic.  they pretend that their lives are all pretty butterflies and they have no problems, ever.  i guess they forgot about american teenagers and their problems.  while parents of nt kids had to impose curfews and stuff due to late night socalizing, i only went out one night a week, and was home by 9 pm most nights, and only stayed out past midnight once without adult supervison, and that was prom night and the dance ended at 12, and i was home at 12:45 am.  so see, parenting an autistic and a nt are very diffrent, but it's not harder or worse, as greentroll is trying to imply.

GreenLion Wrote:
The purpose of the video was specific and narrowly tailored: to emphasize the costs and burdens of autism and to drum up support for a cure.

It's amazing to me that among all the defensive reactions on this forum to the video "we're not ALL like that all the time; autistic people have good days and good times too"; no one thought to realize that the parents in this video are not like that all the time either; and undoubtedly are extremely brave, selfless, loving people who have had to devote their entire lives to their extremely needy children and have set aside their own needs and feelings  for many years.  This may well have been the first time they have opened up to others about the terrible downside that they have to deal with every single day.


so these mothers and advocates that want to call us worthless and kill us off should be called heroes becuase they haevn't done it yet?  i don't think so.  i say they are hateful at best, muderous at worst.  and the way they sound in the video, they weren't being selfless sounding, they sounded like whiny brats that couldn't appreate their kids.

and the problem is that we only see the downside in the video, saying that autism is all bad, and this is how every parent feels about their child, which is false.

GreenLion Wrote:
I have said that autism imposes terrible burdens and difficulties both on those who have it and on those around them.  Pretending otherwise is simply hysterical denial.


well, ntism imposes terrible burdens to everyone around them as well.  does that mean we should wipe it all out?  and autism is a burden only if you let it be that way.  ntism has many obstiables that otherwise healthy (autistic) people would find easy.

GreenLion Wrote:
As for not wanting to become non-autistic, let me turn your question from earlier back at you.  I know you wouldn't take a 100% safe/effective/no side effects autism cure pill.  But would you deny other autistics that choice?  Do you oppose research to develop such a cure?


well, yeah, and who says that you as a non autistic should take away an autistics rights not to be "cured"?  this is the nt inferioity complex into play, nt's know whats best for autistics, not autistics.  we are not denying anyone's rights to be cured, but we are saying we should not be forced to become someone we don't want to be.

Greenlion Wrote:
The purpose of the video was specific and narrowly tailored: to emphasize the costs and burdens of autism and to drum up support for a cure.


too bad it was extremly biased and assumes the extremes as the norms, portays all parents as curebies and that every autistic goes through the same route.  the way they talk about autism, it's like it's the end of the world, and it's false.

GreenLion Wrote:

DM Andy Wrote:
Their kids can be happy, if the parents are prepared to work with them, not seek to turn them into someone they aren't.

I suggest that you hang around here and listen to us.  Then you might realise that we're not so bad, that our "genetic abnormality" doesn't stop us being individuals, being successful in our own ways, being happy.  Then you might realise why we don't want to change.


Who said autistics are bad, or not individuals, or unsuccessful, or unhappy?

I have said that autism imposes terrible burdens and difficulties both on those who have it and on those around them.  Pretending otherwise is simply hysterical denial.

As for not wanting to become non-autistic, let me turn your question from earlier back at you.  I know you wouldn't take a 100% safe/effective/no side effects autism cure pill.  But would you deny other autistics that choice?  Do you oppose research to develop such a cure?


If people accepted them for who they were, instead of constantly abusing them, do you really think that they would want it?  There are many things we are capable of, saying so does not imply that normal socialization is not one of them.  But to say that sustained socializing represents the highest possible good is no less rediculous than saying we have no impairments whatsoever.  

Nobody is saying autistics have no impairments, not even the supremacists.  But these deficits do not outweigh the benefits of a logical, visual mind, and where superior intellect DOES exist, it can be an enormous boon.  I wouldn't trade my incomplete knowledge of German, or even my seriously defective math and physics for all the friends in the universe.  

To you, socialization contains an immense beauty that I am incapable of appreciating.  But do you not realize that my world also has beauty?  Do you deny that German and Irish and Spanish enrich my understanding?  Do you deny the glory of calculus?  Am I under a terrible burden because I LIKE taking derivatives?  Because integration is fun for me?  For me, the logic that underlies this world and the systems therein holds a beauty that you are incapable of appreciating.  This is my love, and it brings me more joy than you could ever get from it.  

And yet for all your lack of understanding, I still accept you as you are.  Your perspective is valid, but so is mine.  That is our premise.  

You are also assuming that the choice would be made by the autistic, but how many autistics have chosen to be in ABA, chelation, on dangerous drugs or unproven diets?  My first experience with mind-altering substances was not as an upperclassman like most kids, it was when I was three years old and the doctors said "Put him on this, he'll stop acting so wierd."  At one point, I was taking seven different pills, all at the same time, and the combination never failed to make me gag.  Those things were huge and I hated them, but I was just a kid then--I had absolutely no choice in the matter.  As a much older kid, it took an entire two years to get off the drugs.  

As has already been said by DM Andy, if the pill existed there would be no choice.  It would be administered no matter what we wanted.

GreenLion Wrote:

Amy Wrote:
GreenLion can you please watch this short video and it might give you some insight into how some of us feel:

http://www.autisticculture.com/autisticvideo/cure.wmv


Thanks, Amy.  My response to that is the same as it has been to other, less eloquent statements in purely verbal form on this board.  No one is attacking or blaming you for the burdens your condition imposes on society, and on you as well.  You should be the most fierce proponents ever for a cure for autism.  Your insistence on taking efforts to cure it as an attack on you worthy of feeling insulted or angry are deeply baffling.



It is baffling because you refuse to see it from our perspective.  We think it is worth it to be this way, and we are far better qualified than you to judge.  More to the point, there are mothers of autistics--Neurotypical mothers of autistics--who have posted that it was worth it to have a kid with autism.  Why should they be ignored?  Why is their perspective less important than mothers guilty of parental misconduct?  

Your perseveration on the idea of a cure belies a lack of understanding about the differences involved in autism.  There are no hormones you can inject.  There is no loose wire that you can just reach in and plug back into its socket.  Our brains are simply very different from yours, and there is nothing that will change that.  It is a rediculous thing to hope.  Why should we be chasing off after some will o' the wisp, when we have the opportunity to stop discrimination, to end the abuse, and improve the lives of all human beings?  Why should we lay aside our good qualities because of the bad?  Why should we give up on our own lives because of other people's lack of vision?

When we use our logic and memory skills, we are not overcoming our autism we are embracing it.  Because, quite frankly, most of us have better things to do than cry over what we do not and cannot have.  It's pointless.  

Quote:
In a sense, autism attacked and changed every "aspie" on this board, inflicting lifelong limitations, problems, and burdens.  If you're feeling sad or frustrated, autism itself should be the target.  Not people who see what you and your families have had to go through and vowed "not for anyone else."


We ARE saying "not for anybody else."  We are saying it about abuse and torture.  We are saying it about job discrimination.  

We are on here demanding justice, when you want us to go chasing after some make-believe pie-in-the-sky "cure."  If you think justice should take a back seat, you need to re-think your value system.  

Quote:
It's almost like Stockholm Syndrome or Battered Wife Syndrome; identifying with someone / something that has victimized and harmed you.  Sorry, I hate amateur pop psychology.  But those are the analogies that popped into my head.


This is simply rediculous.  If you truly believe that, then you have systematically ignored everything we've said.  

You are not qualified to speak about how autistics feel.  That is a simple, objective fact.  We know what we like, we know what we don't like.  It's not so bad, trust me.

GreenLion Wrote:
I'm curious as to why any of that makes a difference.  Truth is truth, and falsehood false, regardless of who says it.


You are not going to have the truth if you never come into contact with it.  That is why it matters.

GreenLion Wrote:

Amy Wrote:
This really is solid proof of the absolute lack of empathy from some NTs towards others.
To others reading this, this is the type of harmful attitude that is given by some people in real life, to our faces.
Directly telling us that we are a burden, and directly after watching a video that tries to explain how disturbing it is to be called that!!!


You certainly deserve respect for your human rights and dignity, and the right to make your own choices.  You also deserve compassion and empathy for any suffering you have experienced for any reason, including as a direct result of autism or because of cruelty you have experienced from others.  You and everyone here have both these things from me, and always have.  

But you can't and won't guilt or intimidate me into denying reality and pretending that falsehood is true by threats that you'll call me un-empathetic.

Facts and reality exist independently of our most intense emotions and desires, and refuse to be held hostage by them.  


This is an enormous non-sequitur.  We are not pretending anything.  Everything we say is true to us.  Who are you, who have none of our experiences, none of our perspective, none of the facts WE have, to say our conclusions are wrong?  

You are completely in the dark on this.  You are attempting to decribe a room that you have never seen.  

Quote:
The reality IS that autism imposes an enormous and ongoing burden, both on people afflicted by it directly and on everyone around them, and on society as a whole.

Why am I so insistent on this point?  Because it is the main reason that a cure for autism is a worthy goal.  Because it is the main reason that the mothers in "Autism Every Day" deserve sympathy, not brutal condemnation.  Because this essential point, this reality of the world, is loudly denied by many on this forum.


Once again, nobody is denying autistics have any difficulty, no one is denying parents of autistics don't have a lot to put up with, no one is denying any of your perseverations.  You have concluded that these issues outweigh any and all other factors, including our own and our parents' desires!  Calling you un-empathetic is not a threat, it is a conclusion that follows directly from the fact that you think these burdens justify our ellimination, the fact that you ignore what an essential part of our being this is, and the fact that you have not responded to any of the parents who have posted directly to you!  

greenlion Wrote:

Amy Wrote:
This same person who thinks we must have ANOTHER condition to autism in order to not want a cure, is the type of person who will support a forced cure on people who appear 'mentally ill' and can't see what is best for them.


Sigh, I probably shouldn't have gone there given the hair-trigger paranoia on this forum.  ("Oops, he mentioned paranoia, another psychiatric condition!  He must want to exterminate us in concentration camps!!"  ReLAX, geez.)  It's just an example what I see as a troubling identification with a debilitating condition.


Your posts are getting more and more desperate, as is plain to see.  Your selective attention is harder and harder for outsiders to ignore as time goes on.  

Quote:
Some militant deaf people and others believe in such constructs as well, viewing people who get surgery to permit hearing as sellouts, labeling and judging people who can hear as if were a cohesive community, and so on.  It's not just "Aspies for Freedom."  Ultimately I think it's about the civil rights paradigm stretched and distorted far beyond any reasonable parameters and into grotesque parody of itself.


Autism includes abilities as well as deficits.  We have said that many times, and you ignore it.  

Quote:
For the record, for the umpteenth time, I already said that I oppose forcing cures on people who don't want them.


How noble of you.  Did it even occur to you that snake-oil cures are ALREADY being forced on autistics, that if there was a cure, it would be administered immediately, and without regard to a person's choice?  You can say you oppose force all you want, that does not change the fact that it will be used.  That is why we demand acceptance.  No one will respect our choices if they see us as defective.  To stop them seeing us as defective, we must stop them seeing us as pitiful wretches.

GreenLion Wrote:

ConLang Wrote:

GreenLion Wrote:
I'm curious as to why any of that makes a difference.  Truth is truth, and falsehood false, regardless of who says it.


You are not going to have the truth if you never come into contact with it.  That is why it matters.


If you are right, then personal experience is the only way to know something.  Then language, the ability to communicate abstract and concrete realities via speech and writing, is pointless.  Recording technology should be discarded.

We shouldn't bother going to school, or watching or reading nonfiction, or talking to friends and others.


You finally respond to a single one of my posts, and it is to twist and distort what I say.  We are using language RIGHT HERE AND NOW to tell you the objective truth of our experiences and you are ignoring it.  

You are trying to take urban legends, stereotypes, and myths, and raise them above what actual, real-life autistics experience.

Quote:
I strongly recall as well the faces of the parents, week after week, the deeply etched lines, wondering just what they had been through, what a struggle it might even have been just to get him dressed and into the church every week, how they must have needed some spiritual solace. I wondered how much he completely consumed and dominated their lives. I also noted their age and wondered what would happen to him after their deaths. I deeply deeply sympathized with them, and with their son, wondering what life was like for them, hoping it wasn't as hard as I feared.


they could be just tired from other stresses, not paturcaly related to their son, and to assume that all autistics are hard to dress is biased and one sided.  they could think that it is a privlege to take care of their autistic son and love doing these things for him, as it could be a joy for them to take care of him, instead of a burden just becuase he's not out of the house and following nt patterns of growth.

when you say dominate, do you mean their love for him or their pain and anguish for having to deal with him?  it could be the first, as the thoughts of the children dominate the parents lives, autistic or not.

and you are assuming that life is worse for them just becuase of a small snippett you see.  this kind of view is very dangerous and assumes that only a normal life is good for a person.  there are many versions of normal, my version is diffrent than yours.  i feel that i'm normal in my sense, but i am diffrent than most, but not a burden.

if all autistics were removed from earth before birth, would the lives of nt's be better or worse?  i would problay say worse.

we are not the no thearpy ever type, it's just the nature of some highly promoted thearpies like aba tend to be abusive and demoralizing to the child, and does more harm than good in their development.

and you precive autistics as defective nt's, which is false.

GreenLion Wrote:

GreenLion Wrote:
The purpose of the video was specific and narrowly tailored: to emphasize the costs and burdens of autism and to drum up support for a cure.

It's amazing to me that among all the defensive reactions on this forum to the video "we're not ALL like that all the time; autistic people have good days and good times too"; no one thought to realize that the parents in this video are not like that all the time either; and undoubtedly are extremely brave, selfless, loving people who have had to devote their entire lives to their extremely needy children and have set aside their own needs and feelings  for many years.  This may well have been the first time they have opened up to others about the terrible downside that they have to deal with every single day.


bravesj858 Wrote:
so these mothers and advocates that want to call us worthless and kill us off should be called heroes becuase they haevn't done it yet?  i don't think so.  i say they are hateful at best, muderous at worst.  and the way they sound in the video, they weren't being selfless sounding, they sounded like whiny brats that couldn't appreate their kids.

and the problem is that we only see the downside in the video, saying that autism is all bad, and this is how every parent feels about their child, which is false.


Did you even read what I wrote and bother to try to consider it, bother to try to see another person's side or empathize with their emotions and situation?  Your loaded, twisted, bitter language is saddening.


why should i empaize with someone who wants to kill me?  what if someone said they wanted to kill you?  would you empathize with that person?  and btw, you are saying that those mothers are the norm for autistic mothers, when they are the extremely deranged, and want to kill us.

GreenLion Wrote:

GreenLion Wrote:
I have said that autism imposes terrible burdens and difficulties both on those who have it and on those around them.  Pretending otherwise is simply hysterical denial.


bravesj858 Wrote:
well, ntism imposes terrible burdens to everyone around them as well.  does that mean we should wipe it all out?  and autism is a burden only if you let it be that way.  ntism has many obstiables that otherwise healthy (autistic) people would find easy.


There's no such thing as "NTism".  Being normal is not a "condition" equivalent to autism.  Seeking emotional and psychological refuge in such false constructs, while no doubt highly tempting and comforting, is ultimately not only a false method of seeking affirmation, but an unnecesary one.  You are not your condition, and you do not have to normalize it to make yourself a valid person.


so everyone should try to acheive one person's version of normal to be a good person.  this is very twisted language and devalues human life on so many levels.  everyone is diffrent, with strenghts and weakness that makes all of us valued to socitey.  and autism is normal for me, that's all i know, being nt is not normal for me and would be a debailting life.  we are not nt's trapped in autism, we are autistic, and trying to vilanize autism as just evil that makes people awful is despictable.


GreenLion Wrote:

bravesj858 Wrote:
well, yeah, and who says that you as a non autistic should take away an autistics rights not to be "cured"?  this is the nt inferioity complex into play, nt's know whats best for autistics, not autistics.  we are not denying anyone's rights to be cured, but we are saying we should not be forced to become someone we don't want to be.


The notion of an "NT inferiority complex" is ludicrous.  Do you really think saying such things makes you an effective and credible advocate?  I suggest you operate in reality.  While it may appear cold and uncomfortable, in the end it will be more satisfying.


i'm saying that our opnion shouldn't be dismmised becuase we are autistic.  so many times, we are silenced becuase we are so called inferior by curebie groups and that we can't speak for ourselves.

would you like it if someone said that your personaity was a harmful disease that was a burden?

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Reference URL's