Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Autism has high costs to U.S. society
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
It can cost about $3.2 million to take care of an autistic person over his or her lifetime. Caring for all people with autism over their lifetimes costs an estimated $35 billion per year. Those figures are part of the findings in the first study to comprehensively survey and document the costs of autism to U.S. society.

Michael Ganz, Assistant Professor of Society, Human Development, and Health at Harvard School of Public Health, authored the study, which appears in a chapter titled, "The Costs of Autism," in the newly published book, Understanding Autism: From Basic Neuroscience to Treatment (CRC Press, 2006). Ganz hopes his research will help policymakers allocate scarce resources to its treatment and prevention as well as provide a useful reference for policymakers and advocates to help them more fully understand the financial impact of autism on U.S. society.

Ganz's analysis of the costs includes direct and indirect medical costs associated with the disorder. But he believes the $35 billion annual societal cost for caring for and treating people with autism likely underestimates the true costs because there are a number of other services that are used to support individuals with autism, such as alternative therapies and other family out-of-pocket expenses, that are difficult to measure. In addition, Ganz believes that the level of cost could be higher if there were more useful and widespread treatment options available. "Given that the federal autism research budget has been historically less than $100 million per year and given that research budgets for other conditions with similar numbers of affected individuals are sometimes orders of magnitude higher, I hope that my research can help focus more attention on directing more resources toward finding prevention and treatment options for autism," Ganz said. (For comparison purposes, he notes estimated annual costs of other conditions, including Alzheimer's disease ($91 billion); mental retardation ($51 billion); anxiety ($47 billion); and schizophrenia ($33 billion).)

Autism is a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) that involves severe deficits in a person's ability to communicate and interact with others. Children with autism often have trouble using their imagination, have a limited range of interests, and may show repetitive patterns of behavior or body movements. The disorder is often associated with some degree of mental retardation. Autism is the most prevalent PDD and the most common of all serious childhood disorders. It affects an estimated 1.5 million Americans and is increasing at a rate of 10-17 percent each year. It is four times more common in boys than in girls. The exact cause of autism is not known and there is currently no cure for the disorder.

Ganz broke down the total costs of autism into two components: direct and indirect costs. Direct costs include direct medical costs, such as physician and outpatient services, prescription medication, and behavioral therapies (estimated to cost, on average, more than $29,000 per person per year) and direct non-medical costs, such as special education, camps, and child care (estimated to annually cost more than $38,000 for those with lower levels of disability and more than $43,000 for those with higher levels).

Indirect costs equal the value of lost productivity resulting from a person having autism, for example, the difference in potential income between someone with autism and someone without. It also captures the value of lost productivity for an autistic person's parents. Examples include loss of income due to reduced work hours or not working altogether. Ganz estimates that annual indirect costs for autistic individuals and their parents range from more than $39,000 to nearly $130,000.

Since people with autism receive services from a wide variety of sources, Ganz believes future research efforts should focus on identifying those sources and linking those costs to non-financial data about the burdens of autism. These complementary sources of data can provide a richer picture that will be useful to policymakers in the future to assist them in devoting resources to address the financial and non-financial effects of autism.
Prevention has a direct meaning as we know autism is genetic. A prenatal test.

As a comparison for something that is preventable -

US prisons Total Federal Inmates:  190,261

Cost just under $5 billion per year.
http://www.usdoj.gov/jmd/2003summary/html/FPScharts.htm
That is the just the cost of prisons, not for police, court, bailliff,  and probation systems.

Cure Crime Now! :evil:
wonder where they got the 3.2 million figure from?  are they assumming autistics never become independent and get a job?  i'll probaly agree autistics probaly cost more to raise than most becuase we need more spefic education that may not be avabile elsewhere, and problay stay home longer than everyone else (like mabye mid 20's than early 20's).

i guess they assume all parents go into the quack cures go around as yongsters, and still are not able to be independent and "leech off their parents" for their whole lives.  this is not true.  if given the right envoriment, we leave the house and become independent (i will do this eventually, when the time is right, i still don't feel ready to leave).  and what about all the hidden autistics that have gotten a job and such.  i guess they want everyone to think autistics never grow up and are forever depedent and nothing good to socitey.

burden, burden, burden...that's all i'm hearing in this article.  bunch of sterotypes.  my family does not think of me as just a burden.  this type of thinking will see that socitey see autistics as someone to get rid of.  our family is stable, and is not like this article says we are.  sterotypes...

yes, amy, the crime system is a bigger concern than autism.  autism is not bad, while crime is bad all the time and burdening down in socitey.  right now, i have a cousin getting in jail for that.  and by the way i've seen prisoners in the fedral system treated, they are getting more rights and privliges than many autistics, who haven't done anything wrong...digusting.  national alliance for crime research/crime speaks... :lol:
From the article -

Direct costs include direct medical costs, such as physician and outpatient services, prescription medication, and behavioral therapies (estimated to cost, on average, more than $29,000 per person per year)

The seems to be calculating the extremely high cost of ABA therapy. That is NOT given to the majority of autistics, and yet this propaganda is being used against all of us as why we need to be prevented.

On the one hand we have the do-gooders who demand ABA from the government that costs thousands of dollars per month, then we get a calculation for the government of how expensive we are to even exist.

This is the deep down harm that curebies are doing with their 'they need help' statistics. The government will never say 'you need help and money, here it is', instead they say 'it costs, remove it'.
they are assuming that all parents are curebies and treat their autistic child exactly the same.  they act as if what happens when someone is autistic, they have to follow a route twoards burden or something.

i have been to the doctors twice in three years, and currently not taking any medication.  i went to a physcarist on and off during childhood, just to have me feel better..never got the purpose for it though...it was usually during stressful times.  but my life wasn't medicalized like the curebies think.  and to my knowlegede, i haven't gone through aba as a youngster, becuase i still acted autistic, and was diagnosed in the late 80's, before the curebie bridgade reared it's head.  the theory back then was to educate the autistic children so that we may be the best we can, instead of trying to take those traits away from them.

bravesj858 Wrote:
wonder where they got the 3.2 million figure from?  


78.6592% of statistics are made up on the spot  :lol:

But seriously... what are they overlooking uh, let's see... only like 10% of autistics need (and recieve) even remotely special care, the 90ish percent seem to get by just fine on more or less normal living conditions (No help, no special education, no meds).

Of that tiny fraction who do need special care, how many of them actually recieve heavy meds, full time care, every type of snake oil under the sun that costs 3.2 million etc required to "cure" [sic] them?

Understanding Autism (Hardcover)
by Steven O. Moldin
List Price: $159.95
Price: $159.95

Editorial Reviews
Review
A variety of illnesses comprise autism spectrum disorders and collectively represent a major medical problem. One can predict that this authoritative collection of essays, representing almost all of the leading workers in this important and growing field of research, will move autism research into a rightfully prominent place in modern medicine.
-- Paul Greengard, Ph.D., Nobel Laureate, Rockefeller University, New York City

A 500-page guide for the march toward a cure for autism. This penetrating overview of cutting-edge neuroscience research and treatment will be invaluable in motivating scientists to study autism, raising public awareness and giving hope to those families who suffer from this devastating disorder.
- Suzanne and Bob Wright, Founders, Autism Speaks, New York City

Moldin and Rubenstein, themselves experts in genetics and developmental neurobiology, have brought together, for the first time, the very best and most creative thinkers in the field. This book, long overdue, is the essential survey and summary of the tremendous advances the last ten years have brought in autism neuroscience. It also serves as a sobering reminder of the hardships that still await families and scientists as they struggle to deal with autism at home and in the lab.
-- Jonathan Shestack, Co-founder, Cure Autism Now, Los Angeles

A variety of illnesses comprise autism spectrum disorders and collectively represent a major medical problem. One can predict that this authoritative collection of essays, representing almost all of the leading workers in this important and growing field of research, will move autism research into a rightfully prominent place in modern medicine.
-- Paul Greengard, Ph.D., Nobel Laureate, Rockefeller University, New York City

A 500-page guide for the march toward a cure for autism. This penetrating overview of cutting-edge neuroscience research and treatment will be invaluable in motivating scientists to study autism, raising public awareness and giving hope to those families who suffer from this devastating disorder.
- Suzanne and Bob Wright, Founders, Autism Speaks, New York City


Moldin and Rubenstein, themselves experts in genetics and developmental neurobiology, have brought together, for the first time, the very best and most creative thinkers in the field. This book, long overdue, is the essential survey and summary of the tremendous advances the last ten years have brought in autism neuroscience. It also serves as a sobering reminder of the hardships that still await families and scientists as they struggle to deal with autism at home and in the lab.
n and Rubenstein, themselves experts in genetics and developmental neurobiology, have brought together, for the first time, the very best and most creative thinkers in the field. This book, long overdue, is the essential survey and summary of the tremendous advances the last ten years have brought in autism neuroscience. It also serves as a sobering reminder of the hardships that still await families and scientists as they struggle to deal with autism at home and in the lab.

Book Description
Integrating basic and clinical neuroscience perspectives, Understanding Autism: From Basic Neuroscience to Treatment presents a comprehensive perspective on state-of-the-art research in epidemiology, genetics, and clinical neuroscience and neural systems implicated in autism. This book seeks to stimulate new directions for autism research on etiology, pathophysiology, and the development of new drug treatment. An underlying theme focuses on the potential for future research given the availability of the human, mouse, and other genomes. The text also explores the role of autism in society, including health economics and advocacy issues of interest to legislators.
Product Details

    * Hardcover: 552 pages
    * Publisher: CRC; 1st edition (April 25, 2006)
    * Language: English
    * ISBN: 0849327326

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0849327...e&n=283155
sounds like a curebie book.  and why when they try to undestand autism, they never ask us a thing?  i keep asking that.  these people only know through third person experine about autism, while we have first hand experince with autism becuase we live the autism life everyday..and it's not despiar.

i know more about myself than some curebie that relies on sterotypes of my kind.

i'm not a medical problem...i don't go to doctors all the time about me being autistic...in fact i've avoided doctors for a while...(just becuase).  sterotyping autism is a major problem though.

and a cure means annilation.  i don't want that.

and mr. shestack, can founder is assuming that all familes with autistic people in it are hoping for a cure...that is not true.  mabye a sobering reminder for curebies.

a must avoid book.
The book is mentioned in the above article.

I did a quick background check on Michael Ganz:

http://www  .hsph.  har  vard.edu/faculty/MichaelGanz.html

He does not just study autism, so he probably just viewed it as another socioeconomic factor to study. :evil:
i checked the numbers, and using their estimates, that means per autistic, we cost around 23,333.33 per year.  that should just about cover my tution, wish they were supporting that instead.  well, excuse me, what about the rest of socitey that is leeching off the system?  i guess to them, we are forever dependent and touturing our familes or some stupid excuse.  autistics are completly capable, and if the curebies have it their way, we don't get that chance to prove it...

if every autistic is owed 3.2 million, i don't have to work a day in my life, i'll probaly travel the world and make my life worth while...or i can stay in college forver. :lol:

but seriously, they are probaly taking the estimate of the curebies and their efforts and assume every austic goes through that, and that they will never grow up without a cure.  i have seen lots of autistic people have jobs and support themselves...probaly the majorty.  i'm not a leech off the system, but i'm still in college, that will change in the not too distant future though.

in short, autism isn't expensive...rhetoric and sterotypes are.

bravesj858 Wrote:
if every autistic is owed 3.2 million, i don't have to work a day in my life, i'll probaly travel the world and make my life worth while...or i can stay in college forver. :lol:


Hell yeah, I'll stop paying my taxes, mortgage, daughter's school fees, etc. and join you!! :smile:

Actually, I've paid taxes from the age of eighteen and never once had any sort of parking ticket or fine for speeding, always EXTREMELY law abiding, never once been on welfare, etc. Those statistics just don't get taken into account by the people who throw around "3.2 million" like it's some sort of mantra.  I'd say they should look at people with Aspergers and other high-functioning autistics and see how much we've given to society with inventions, innovations, etc. that NTs would probably not have thought of by themselves.

Alison

Quote:
giving hope to those families who suffer from this devastating disorder.


Quote:
It also serves as a sobering reminder of the hardships that still await families and scientists as they struggle to deal with autism at home and in the lab.


hmm....that sounds nowhere near what my family is.  mabye they feel that way about autistics, but not all of us do.  they don't struggle with me, seeing me as a part of a plague, they see me as a unique and speical person, although i was a bit spoiled (not too much though).  we aldedy have hope, a cure will not be hope, it will be devsation to everyone that knows me if i was "cured".

question, when they say these things "familes struggle with autism", do they imply all familes with autstics, or just the curebies?

Amy Wrote:
Prevention has a direct meaning as we know autism is genetic. A prenatal test.

As a comparison for something that is preventable -

US prisons Total Federal Inmates:  190,261

Cost just under $5 billion per year.
http://www.usdoj.gov/jmd/2003summary/html/FPScharts.htm
That is the just the cost of prisons, not for police, court, bailliff,  and probation systems.

Cure Crime Now! :evil:

And other things given their figures on autism count lost earning which applies here as well, and for crime you have various financial costs of the crimes themselves not to meantion the costs of insurance etc everyone looses out on to protect themselves from said crime allong with victim services, lost working hours due to various aspects of trauma for victims of crime etc.

Alot more autistic people would be working if there was not such systematic discrimination against them in hiring processes, some minimal support was offered to them to keep employment (what would have helped me), and that placements might be arranged by some agency instead of relying on people with autism to make their own contacts and find their own employment.
Reference URL's