Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: "Nature" article: Brain deficits found in relative
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Brain deficits found in relatives of autism sufferers
Unaffected family members show characteristic abnormalities.

Jim Giles
Nature
14 November 2005

Running in the family? Relatives of autistic patients may have some of the same brain features, but no symptoms.

People can have physical brain abnormalities similar to those found in autistic individuals without having the disorder themselves. These results come from two studies, which were presented at a conference over the weekend. Brain scans show striking similarities between the brains of autistic patients and those of their non-autistic parents and siblings.

The results are prompting researchers to ask how some people can be unaffected by brain deficits that cause such pronounced behavioural abnormalities in others.

In one study, Eric Peterson of the University of Colorado at Boulder and his colleagues scanned the brains of 40 parents of autistic children and compared the results with functional magnetic imaging (MRI) scans from 40 controls. The data look much like those obtained for comparisons between autistic and non-autistic brains, says Peterson. The results were discussed on 13 November at the annual meeting of the Society for Neuroscience in Washington.

Some areas of the brain region known as the prefrontal cortex were smaller than normal in the parents of autistic children, for example. This part of the brain is involved in understanding other peoples' motivations, something that autistic people find difficult and is thought to lie behind the problems they face in interacting socially.

Another typical symptom of autism is the tendency to avoid making eye contact. This behaviour was studied by Brendon Macewicz and colleagues at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. He gave nine families with an autistic child and unaffected brother a digital camera and told them to take pictures of friends and family. Macewicz then mixed up the shots with images of strangers and tracked the childrens' eye movements while asking them to say whether the people they saw in the pictures were familiar or not.

Most people rely heavily on looking at the eyes when asked to complete this task. But autistic children are known to avoid the eyes and focus on other aresas of the face. To Macewicz's surprise, the non-autistic siblings did almost exactly the same.

"This piqued our curiosity," he says. The team then ran MRI scans on the brothers, focussing on the part of the brain known as the amygdala. This area is involved in fear and is typically smaller in autistic people. "It was very interesting," says Macewicz. "The children showed a similar decrease in amygdala size to their autistic siblings." The difference was around 5-10%.

The results are intriguing, say the researchers, because the parents and siblings had not been diagnosed with autism. Macewicz says it is likely that in the unaffected siblings other brain areas, perhaps in the frontal lobes, are helping to regulate the amygdala and compensate for its smaller volume.

It may be that a core set of brain abnormalities has to be present for autism to occur, adds Peterson, and that the parents he studied do not have them all. He points out that some autism-related behavioural traits have previously been seen in the relatives of people with the condition, but that these current studies are among the first to show similarities in brain anatomy.

*************************************************************
It sounds like the parents could either be on the spectrum and not diagnosed, or have traits. But I dont see this as surprising as parents pass on their genes to their children, and kids are like their parents. If two parents are aspie like, the child could have a diagnosis, and if only one parent was aspie like the child could just have traits, as a rough example.
Good.  Now when my family make fun of me or criticize me because of my AS then I can tell them that they probably have brain damage too.
It might take a certain combination of genetic variations (plus environmental signals during development) to result in the autistic phenotype--if one part of the combo is inherited from mom and another part from dad, then the kid could have the phenotype and the parents each not--also, because each parent can donate one of two chromosomes, each kid can get a different combination of variants.

E.g. in my family, my older sister has OCD but I don't--what if we each inherited the same predisposing genetic variant from our mother (who's not exactly normal but not OCD or Aspie) and a different one from Dad, who was pretty neurotypical--I have a great Uncle on Dad's side who easily could have been Aspie.  My next younger sister is very NT but my youngest sister, who may be borderline ADD has a daughter who is ADD. So the variants swimming in the gene pool can combine in diverse ways.

This makes it really hard to sort out what "causes" what, or even what correlates with what.  Same problem with multigenic diseases such as type 1 diabetes
It seems to make nonsense of the whole MMR/Thimerosal/Poisoned Child theory of autism.

Stella
lol, M. Don't say that 'cause that would imply autism is brain damage, not neurodiversity.
Reference URL's