Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Do Aspies really feel love for others?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
http://www.suite101.com/article.cfm/adul...ers/115303

Author:  A.J. Mahari
Published on: April 12, 2005

Recola, who has an aspie boyfriend and posted in the discussion area of this topic posted on April 5, 2005 describing some difficulty encountered with her aspie boyfriend. She described his not being there for her in times of needing emotional support and understanding when she needs space due to her own stresses and/or his not fully understanding her need for space when she feels this way.

She asked this question: “Do Aspies really feel love for others or do they just stay with people who give them a comfort level?” and described that her aspie boyfriend seems to take leave of the relationship when she is depressed and that things seem to switch from him professing his love for her to him saying to her that "You need a helpful loving person, someone who can get you through those tough times that you have. I don't have the energy for that".

The first thing I want to make really clear in response to this is that each and every person with Asperger’s Syndrome (AS) has their own individual responses to life, to the stress of relating. Each individual person with Asperger’s has varying degrees of understanding of “other”. Whether or not Recola’s boyfriend can actually understand what her stresses or feelings of depression are like and what she needs and why or not is not clear. He may well not be able to empathize. Some people with AS lack empathy. Some have empathy and can’t express it. Some both have empathy and express it in their own ways.

It is important to remain cognizant of the fact that each and every situation for those who are involved in relationships with those with AS is somewhat individually different. There is no blanket statement to be made that every aspie will do this or that or not be able to do this or that relationally.

Asperger’s Syndrome is indeed a complication to many aspects of relating generally and specifically in interpersonal relationships for most. I believe that those of us with AS can learn to compensate for that which we don’t understand very well. We can learn how to meet our partner’s needs, or at the very least how not to stress them more when they are facing emotional turmoil or other life challenges.

To the question posed, “Do Aspies really feel love for others or do they just stay with people who give them a comfort level?” forgive me for sounding like a broken record when I say that it is such an individual thing. There is no lumping us all together generally or when It comes to the ability (or perhaps lack thereof) to relate to a significant other. What it sounds like the aspie described by this poster to the discussion area of this topic is struggling with is lack of emotional reciprocity. This may well be because he, like many with AS, has mind blindness, which is described through the “Theory of Mind”

Theory of mind, or mind blindness is an impairment that those with AS must learn to compensate for to one degree or another in order to maintain heathy and functional relationships with those who are Neuro-typical (NT).

Those with AS may lack the ability to be able to consider, understand, and cope with other people’s thoughts and feelings. There may be times when an aspie may have a degree of understanding but not have found a way to communicate that understanding in a way that an NT would readily comprehend. This reality can lead to difficulties in the areas of trying to comprehend the intentions, motivations, and subsequent actions and feelings of others.

If you are in a relationship with someone with Asperger's you must remember that NT's and those with AS do not share similiar ways of processing information and/or communicating. So to highten the chances of successful communication each must be willing to be patient in hearing the other.

People with AS may also lack understanding of their own emotions and/or the emotions of others. This often manifests as a lack of empathy.

At times any lack of understanding of emotions, one's own or those of others, can be the result of the time it takes aspies to process information. Sometimes, just allowing the person with AS a little more time will help him or her to identify what they feel or to understand more about what an NT feels.

There are compensatory strategies that can build strength and more understanding to decrease the impact and potential negative effects this impairment. This has been my experience. However, that said, not all aspie’s will be able to make these efforts or even desire to consider making these efforts to learn to bridge the emotional and social gaps between themselves and those who are NT.

To answer the question then, I believe that aspies really do love others in their own way. What that way ends up being, looks like or consists of varies. As an aspie who has stretched and grown in compensatory ways in this area myself I know that in my own case I am not seeking to be in a relationship in the search for some comfort level. Comfort is often elusive and over-shadowed by the anxiety that presents when I am relating to my partner. So to the degree that any aspie seeks to be in relationship to another (and especially an other who is NT) I believe that in most cases this would be from a place of love – love as the aspie understands it which may be quite different and much more limited than an NT understanding and experience of love.

When Recola’s aspie boyfriend says he doesn’t have the energy to cope with her emotional state or needs this may be the product to some degree of mind blindness. It may also have a lot to do with the stress that dealing with emotions causes many with AS.

The bottom line here for Recola, or anyone who is NT in a relationship with someone with AS is that you have to decide what you need. You have to clearly ask yourself what you can and cannot live with.

I would encourage each individual NT in relationship to a person with AS to also consider just where on the spectrum their desired significant other is. I say this because I know from my own experience as a high functioning aspie that I can be taught how to respond to what my partner needs. I continue to educate myself and to challenge myself to learn and grow and adapt the best I can. My partner continues to learn how to best cope with the areas that present difficulties for her and then we both work at communicating and understanding each other.

I do not believe that aspies just stay with people who give them a comfort level because the exposure anxiety and general stress involved in relating are often formidable and for most I believe would be (as in my case) motivated by very real feelings of love. The territory that those with AS have to navigate to express love and to cope with relating is very different from the terrain traveled by those who are NT.

These relationships, between those with AS and NT's require continued effort on both people’s part to address the challenges that will present themselves and it is crucial to understand that all that a couple seeks to mirror to and for each other within a relationship will be two very distinct reflected images presented in very differing styles of relating, communicating, and emotional expression.

It is therefore very important that assumptions aren't made "facts". Each person, and perhaps even moreso the NT in the relationship need to clarify and re-clarify things in order to accuately understand the feelings and intentions of his or her partner.
If someone is in a relationship that is not suited to them, they will have problems, aspie or NT.
Do aspies feel love?  

We're all human, we're not aliens from anoher galaxy, though I guess we might appear that way to some.
Questions for aspies -

"Do Aspies really feel love for others"

and coming soon...."Do aspies really breathe" and "Do aspies ever eat".

(sarcasm)
This is why I'm not too fond of sites that make pop-culture claims like "Data from Star Trek: The Next Generation is a perfect example of Asperger's Syndrome".



Aside from being not just a bit personally insulting and infuriating, it helps to propagate the stereotype of emotionless Aspie. If Aspies were emotionless, why would cyclical depression be so common with Asperger's Syndrome? People don't seem to understand that zero emotion and a difficulty or inability to express those emotions are two different things.


While it is true that I can become detached from the feelings of others (in fact, have often been made to feel guilty when I don't display a proper emotional reaction), I can at least sympathize. It's not empathy in the classical sense (I feel no compulsion to emotional expression based solely on the emotional expressions of others); instead, it's a realization (yes, even against all my perceptions) that other people do indeed have emotions, motivations and ideas. As such, I should attempt to treat them with the respect I accord myself. I'm an altruist, in that I'll try to help anyone with any problems they have, practical or emotional; I may not know that help is needed until asked, however. In the context of a romantic relationship, I can see how this aspect may spoof certain NT's into believing those with AS do not feel love. One of the sub-definitions of love is an innate understanding of the other person, a feat which often stands outside the Aspie's capacity. There is no reason, however, that an Aspie cannot fulfill 90% of the requirements for love (fidelity, protection of mutual interest, companionship, and yes, even emotional support when asked, and instructed as to what kind of support would be most meaningful in a given situation).

Quote:
I know from my own experience as a high functioning aspie that I can be taught how to respond to what my partner needs.


Did anybody else wince when they read this sentence?

It seems to suggest that only the most high functioning aspies are romantically educable, as if a relationship were an exercise in dog training, and only some dogs were sufficiently capable of learning the skills.  Ick.  Bleah.

I would never use the term "high functioning" to refer to myself (or to any other human being).  Machines function.  People live.

Bonnie Ventura wrote

Quote:
Quote:
I know from my own experience as a high functioning aspie that I can be taught how to respond to what my partner needs.


Did anybody else wince when they read this sentence?

It seems to suggest that only the most high functioning aspies are romantically educable, as if a relationship were an exercise in dog training, and only some dogs were sufficiently capable of learning the skills. Ick. Bleah.

I totally agree. And how sincere and meaningful would the trained aspie's response to their partner be, if it is all pretty much pre-programmed by the other partner? I wouldn't want or value or enjoy trained responses to my emotional needs. I'd rather have a partner that gives few expressions of affection that are genuinely felt.


Quote from article

Quote:
“Do Aspies really feel love for others or do they just stay with people who give them a comfort level?”

What a stupid *** question. Speaking for myself, I have been in relationships of varying levels of seriousness with NTs, and relationships with NTs have no level of comfort at all for me. Being with NTs puts me on edge because I never know what caper they are going to come up with or what unwarranted assumption they are going to make next, so it stands to reason that I had some feelings for the NT ex-boyfriends, why else would I have been in the relationships at all in the first place?

Speaking for myself again, I don't need to be with a partner or any group of people to maintain a "comfort level". I'm happy to live on my own if there is no special person in my life. So obviously I don't stay in meaningless relationships just to stay emotionally comfortable. NTs do that kind of thing because they generally do need to be around others to maintain comfort levels.

I've been married to another undiagnosed aspie for many years. There is a high comfort level in our relationship, but there's much more to it than that.

"Men are from Earth. Women are from Earth. Autistic people are also from Earth. Get Over It!"

I like it. :smile:
I thought up the end bit myself. The first part of the quote is from the book "Sex, Lies & Stereotypes: Challenging Views of Women, Men, and Relationships" by Dr Gary Wood, which I have not read, but might in the future.

If you want to use the slogan in any way, go for it, you're most welcome.
Thanks, I came up with one thinking about the cure issue -
Money is the root of all cure.
I've got to agree with that slogan. Somehow I have found my way onto the mailing list of some crowd who flog "treatments" for CAPD. I don't think there is any solid evidence that CAPD can be treated or cured, but a group associated with local university are holding a seminar about a treatment and interventions for CAPD, and of course the seminar tickets are quite expensive. They overcharge for their auditory testing too.
Could this Recola woman be a bit of a whinger?
I feel love for many people. In different ways of course. Although I may spend quite a bit of time by myself, I never want to be totally alone. That would be horrible.

rossco

7 O'Clock same with my kids!
I don' understand empathy or social conventions very well but I do love.
Example: I do not buy flowers after a fight - Isn't that reinforcing and rewardig bad behaviour?

Example: I do not understand what someone may be feeling or feel connected to their pain.

HOWEVER Any love is self directed. I don't react to others or to set situations. I am self-directed and personal with dishing out love, in whatever form that takes. Sure I may not understand why someone is crying or offer the right alternative of response but I will still give and am very giving and caring.

Does any of this make sense?

rossco

Well said 7 O'Clock I agree.
Pages: 1 2 3
Reference URL's