Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Stupid Diagnoses.
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Welcome to the Forums Alias Pseudonym.

Why would a 'completely non-distractible state' be a non-aspie trait?

I've scored 160-185 on the aspie quiz. My sense of directions are also impeccable as is my balance.

I'm 42. How old are you?


Tomas

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
What I meant by non-distractible was that I can be pulled away from it and go right back--that's non-aspie, isn't it?




Maybe, I don't know. Autism is a spectrum of traits, some you may fit, some your wont. Maybe aspergers isn't quite right, maybe traits of autism may be be more on mark. It's a bit of an art, more than a science.

I love your writing, you're brilliant. Your writing is very relaxed, informal and off the cuff.

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
Finally, I took some of you're aspie tests and they all say 'no you're not an aspie.'  So, assuming you care to read my tiny autobiography, do you think I am or not?  I'm really smart, maybe I'm just aping normal behavior well.


You definitely don't get any points for humility.

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
What I meant by non-distractible was that I can be pulled away from it and go right back--that's non-aspie, isn't it?


I think it is non-Aspie.  Personally, if you pull me away from my hyperfocused state, it is very hard for me to get back into it.

I think you may be "gifted ADHD" instead, and the Asperger could be wrong.

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
...  I've been officially diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome.  I'm not sure I actually have it, but I have.  I've also been diagnosed with AD-HD (which I definitely have) and Anxiety Disorder NOS (if never worrying about anything is an anxiety disorder, this is spot on.)

...


It seems that either your ADHD messes up the online test results or you've been the 'victim' of a sort of 'fashion' among professionals to dx Asperger's if they don't know what to write down.

Even if - you're still welcome to write here.

That's a really good idea Yigal.

Good to see you are posting. Smile

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
Finally, I took some of you're aspie tests and they all say 'no you're not an aspie.'  So, assuming you care to read my tiny autobiography, do you think I am or not?  I'm really smart, maybe I'm just aping normal behavior well.


I don't know why people seem to keep insisting on this, but really I do not see why being exceptionally smart would allow you to mimic social behavior any better than an Aspie of average intelligence.

There are bright NTs who don't do too well socially.

I think your theory is incorrect.  Again, for the masses, if you happen to be very smart with Asperger's... the giftedness wouldn't necessarily compensate for social problems.  Trust me.

IncognitoInnominate Wrote:
hah... D is for DARK and i'm DONE.
Should of got a commendment. Nice.

i don't think aspies in general have a typicly bad sense of direction, varies through everyone AS or not.  But on the balance thing no Aspie male i have met can dance.  I tried... girls can though. (I think it's the limping thing in the left leg. gonna poll this.)


I have an incredibly bad sense of direction.  I am 26 and have lived in the same neighborhood my whole life, and I still cannot give anyone directions to anyone beyond a simple "go past this one light, take a left, keep going for a while" etc.  I still get lost in my own neighborhood.

I think a bad sense of direction is typical for Aspies.

Batman55 Wrote:

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
Finally, I took some of you're aspie tests and they all say 'no you're not an aspie.'  So, assuming you care to read my tiny autobiography, do you think I am or not?  I'm really smart, maybe I'm just aping normal behavior well.


I don't know why people seem to keep insisting on this, but really I do not see why being exceptionally smart would allow you to mimic social behavior any better than an Aspie of average intelligence.

There are bright NTs who don't do too well socially.

I think your theory is incorrect.  Again, for the masses, if you happen to be very smart with Asperger's... the giftedness wouldn't necessarily compensate for social problems.  Trust me.


I agree. There have been a number of autistic people considered to be quite intelligent who couldn't socialize for beans (possibly why we get the 'eccentric professor' stereotype). Academic skills won't do much for socialization, unless you happen to find yourself in a lot of academic clubs, where people are similarly nerdy, and because of mutual knowledge, the difference in social skills may not be so pronounced. But that's when talking about special interests, and even then you can go off on tangents and stand out from the rest.

As mentioned before, autism is a spectrum so that, there are some people who'll meet all the criteria, others who will meet some (but still enough for a diagnosis), and others who'll meet some but not enough for a diagnosis. Autistic traits aren't exclusively the domain of autistics, and that's how I think of the spectrum anyway - continuous, including autistic, not very autistic at all, and every place in between. In any case, you're still welcome on the boards. There are a number of us who have ADHD as well, and there are also NT members, so feel free to post here as much as you like.

Alias Pseudonym Wrote:
After think about this more than I have in, well, ever (and after gripping that there isn't an edit button to let me avoid double posting.) I've decided I don't have Asperger's Syndrome.  I have personality traits and abilities associated with it, but to have a syndrome you have to have symptoms, and after going over mine I realised all of them are associated with AD-HD rather than AS.


If you hadn't known, many people with ADHD have some traits and personality characteristics that overlap with Asperger's, in the first place.  Some researchers believe ADHD may be on the autistic spectrum.

Marcia Wrote:

honestjohn Wrote:
I think (may be a controvesial thought) that alot of the kids classified as ADHD, are ADHD like, but not gentically born ADHD, the environment they are in makes them act as such. (parental techniques, starting a kid at school too soon, too much Tv at 1 year old etc., ) While there are many ADHD that no changes in parenting will change.  Just an opinion.  (whereas ASD is not a parent issue, in any cases, it has a physical/nuerological basis)  Nurture Vs. nature.


I would tend to agree with this, in some cases anyway.  

I've seen concern expressed in the media about the number of children dxed as ADHD and medicated when it may simply be the case that adults are failing to realise that children do have loads of energy and if they are denied the opportunity to run that energy off or express themselves as children should then their activities will become more destructive.  They say that children are given much less freedom these days just to be children and to enjoy unsupervised, or minimally supervised outdoor play.  Instead they are kept indoors and expected to act more like mini-adults than as children.  Medication is used to keep them placid and more controllable. Better to let them run about in the park for an afternoon and burn off all that energy!

Btw, I'm not saying this applies to all children dxed as ADHD, but quite possibly to some.


I think this is true for those who have been misdiagnosed with ADHD, while for people who the diagnosis fits probably wouldn't make any difference. Especially the school system, expects kids to have to sit still for way too long at a time.

Quote:
On the other hand I have near-perfect balance, an impeccable sense of direction (I spend much of my time wandering unfamiliar suburbs alone on roller skates), good motor skills both gross and fine (although my handwriting is appalling,) a good sense of rhythm and timing, good colour judgment, and at least a rudimentary ability to know when to talk and when to shut up in conversation.  Also I understand eye contact bothers some people but it has less affect on me than on most NTs.  I do stare sometimes but I'll recognise I must be bothering the other person.


None of those rule out Asperger Syndrome.
Making eye contact, rudimentary social understanding, etc indicate better social skills than the stereotype of Asperger Syndrome, but if you still have social impairment you'd just be mild AS.
I've found (from personal experience) that it's hard to self-assess social skills. Have you tried filling out an online test with someone else who knows you well? You might find you've been underestimating how autistic you are.
On the other hand, autistic traits are common in ADHD. In addition to inattentiveness, hyperfocusing on an area of interest can be seen in ADHD. The big difference is that social problems for ADHDers are caused by inattentiveness or impulsiveness, not lack of understanding.
If you're not AS, you are probably gifted/ADHD, as someone else suggested.

Did you have a look at the ICD-10? Perhaps you can guess somehow what 'triggered' the thought about Anxiety with your doc?

Quote:
F41 Other anxiety disorders
Disorders in which manifestation of anxiety is the major symptom and is not restricted to any particular environmental situation. Depressive and obsessional symptoms, and even some elements of phobic anxiety, may also be present, provided that they are clearly secondary or less severe.
...
F41.9 Anxiety disorder, unspecified
Anxiety NOS


Some behaviour which is due to being an Aspie might be interpreted as being a symptom of anxiety, I think.

You could check out the official diagnostic criteria. Keep in mind that to say "yes" to a symptom you have to have it in a significant way--something that you have to work around somehow, or something that interferes with your life, or something you do a lot more, worse, or less than other people. There's a gray area between autism and not-autism that describes a lot of people with autistic traits who aren't quite autistic...

Anyway, welcome Smile
Pages: 1 2 3 4
Reference URL's