Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Problem is, it's not valid..
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.

Batman55 Wrote:
In another thread, you folks have said my creativity is an indication that I have intelligence, despite my claims to the contrary.  Tonight I just realized my creativity is probably the result of very slow-processing speed, executive dysfunction, and learning challenges...  all of which, combined, results in me taking significantly longer time to "capture" details than the average person.  In so doing, I can detect patterns and see associations in things, that other people might just skip right past because faster processing speed usually just takes the necessary data.

I said in another thread tonight that this kind of intelligence does not "count," because it's the result of a seriously flawed brain.  What's more, how can you use this kind of creativity in a productive or meaningful way, if you don't have the executive functions or the processing power to "go the distance" ?  This has been my life experience... the ideas are there, but the ability to start, execute, and complete is almost entirely missing.  So I feel this does not count and it certainly does not make me "intelligent."

I still am looking for the reason I have been brought into existence.  I don't believe I will "fall back" on being a righteous human being in absence of anything that works properly in my brain.  Ever stop to ask yourself why learning disabled people are the nicest folks you'll ever meet?

Gee....  I wonder  RolleyesRolleyesRolleyes


Batman55,
  Ok, you've gained some insight into your nature; now you need to *find* a way to put it to good use.  Smile

  Ask yourself: is there a way you can find someone who can help you *compensate* for your limitations? You might not be able to do things yourself, but as part of a team (not necessarily one you have to be in close contact with), you can do your part, give the results to them, and *they* can implement it.

  -BobB

Anyhow. Any more and I'm charging $100 dollars and hour.
Intelligence is multifarious. We are barely capable of defining it, let alone quantifying it. Degrees are status symbols that mean nothing. I have some, but the vast majority of my knowledge was acquired independently. There is but one purpose in this short life: to know thyself. Things are somewhat absurd, and every individual (whether NT or not) grapples with a largely chaotic and untrammelled world. It is a case of establishing an informative connection between thought and the material; you are not obliged to do so swiftly or conventionally. You have to find your own meaning, your own joy and your own successes. You are who you are. Nothing can change that. As for education? Read, paint, live and watch. Everyone has their limitations. At the end, we are all human. You write and express yourself far too well to be considered cognitively deficient. Have some confidence.

Batman55 Wrote:
I don't know if you have executive dysfunction or not, but it pretty much takes away my ability to plan anything.


you dont need university ,you should go to trade school

Batman55 Wrote:
As far as using academic ability to measure intelligence, that's done all the time at least where I live.  Where I live, people generally seem to be judged on the merit of their accomplishments, esp. academic achievements.  Basic conversation about college, where I live:  "X or Y person went to X or Y Good College and finished on time, achieved well on the debate team, and was a RA who was also dean-listed.  He's always been very bright."

But I've never overheard a conversation that says "X or Y person did not go to college, did poorly in high school with no extracurriculars, lacks cognitive flexibility, cannot plan anything beyond 5 minutes, and has achieved nothing.  He's always been very bright."

See what I mean?  Rolleyes


RA? Dean-listed? I do not understand these colloquialisms. No need to be ashamed.

Inferiority complex? No. Do not judge yourself against others. Judge yourself absolutely and as an individual

Wondering1 Wrote:
Intelligence is multifarious. We are barely capable of defining it, let alone quantifying it. Degrees are status symbols that mean nothing. I have some, but the vast majority of my knowledge was acquired independently. There is but one purpose in this short life: to know thyself. Things are somewhat absurd, and every individual (whether NT or not) grapples with a largely chaotic and untrammelled world. It is a case of establishing an informative connection between thought and the material; you are not obliged to do so swiftly or conventionally. You have to find your own meaning, your own joy and your own successes. You are who you are. Nothing can change that. As for education? Read, paint, live and watch. Everyone has their limitations. At the end, we are all human. You write and express yourself far too well to be considered cognitively deficient. Have some confidence.



This is beautifully written, Wondering1.

Batman55 Wrote:

Hmm, perhaps I'm not understanding what you mean in this example...  I don't get what you're saying, in other words.


What I'm trying to say is that a person with aspergers sees the world of social relations around them and feels somehow unable to participate fully in an idealised world. In actuality true friends are few and far between, while people may use each other as stepping stones to get what they want, be that lower overhead, money, sex, social caste, or even a sounding board for their ideas.

I'll admit it, Batman, I'm selfish. I like to get my ideas out there as a kind of self-therapy.

Batman55 Wrote:
  At least on that basis, it would be hard to convince anyone that I don't have PDD.

And.. what do you mean by experiential learning?  I'm not sure why you think socializing with others in my age group would help with my inferiority complex, etc.


I only mean experiential learning such as a job where you are forced to interact to a degree, and then you can decide where you fit in from there. A college provides an environment where there is some level of socialisation outside of work. Sure, others may step on your feelings at times, but then, you can pull back to whatever comfort level you so choose.

Some interaction might cut the cycle of self-deprecating rumination.

I do not understand this obsession with college. I have met so many brilliant autodidacts.

GuessWho Wrote:
Wondering1 et al, I had the Master's, and just like in the movie Independence Day, I felt like the B2 pilot firing the nuclear missile at the UFO over Houston-- it should have been destroyed, nothing can withstand an H bomb right?  that's why the Defense Secretary was overconfident they got it.... but they didn't get it..... the shields even withstood an H bomb

I changed careers and got a community college certificate in computer programming.  It is kind of like attacking by going around, and it did, after some false starts like in the movie (the morale is keep shooting), I got hired in 6 weeks after graduation in 1999.  It has now been 8.5 entire years since going salaried.  Happy anniversary.


If I were not in academics I would not be employable. Simple as that.

Wondering1 Wrote:
I do not understand this obsession with college. I have met so many brilliant autodidacts.


It's not really an obsession as such with college, but instead there is a possibility that Batman555 might meet others of a similar intelligence level. Aspies abound at colleges, and so, such an environment might be actually less of a challenge socially, and one in which he might find his own niche.

You don't have to have any particular skills to work at a college office. I once knew a girl that had dropped out of high school and returned to school in her mid 30's. She started by working in one of the departments, btw one which was not her eventual major.

Besides there are events with free tickets, there are a myriad of social groups, there are professional fraternities that only meet to discuss their own majors. There are so many special interests that it would be hard not to find one in which to interact, even if on a limited basis.

As for me, I've either never lived close enough to a college or university to do more than attend classes once or twice per week. Also, there is the issue of very limited pay, and I've had to pay my own way most of my life.

Batman55 Wrote:
In another thread, you folks have said my creativity is an indication that I have intelligence, despite my claims to the contrary.  Tonight I just realized my creativity is probably the result of very slow-processing speed, executive dysfunction, and learning challenges...  all of which, combined, results in me taking significantly longer time to "capture" details than the average person.  


Do you know that people with asperger's often are much better at book learning than picking up details quickly in a classroom.

As far as executive dysfunction goes you write far too well, and far too clearly for this to be a problem.

There really is no valid, testable hypothesis to explain what you feel.

Rather than quote or misquote the rest of what you've stated I leave you with this one word, "Depression".

Batman55 Wrote:

Saint Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:
In another thread, you folks have said my creativity is an indication that I have intelligence, despite my claims to the contrary.  Tonight I just realized my creativity is probably the result of very slow-processing speed, executive dysfunction, and learning challenges...  all of which, combined, results in me taking significantly longer time to "capture" details than the average person.  


Do you know that people with asperger's often are much better at book learning than picking up details quickly in a classroom.

As far as executive dysfunction goes you write far too well, and far too clearly for this to be a problem.


I am very sleep deprived, angry, and feeling very unhealthy at the moment so I won't have the brainpower to explain myself in detail.  But I can say this:  I'm afraid you've got that wrong.  If I feel better by the time my nightly routine comes along tomorrow, you may have the explanation.

For what it's worth, if you haven't figured it out, I stick by a very strict, tight routine that I do not deviate from and that includes visiting AFF among other websites, every night.

Saint Wrote:
Rather than quote or misquote the rest of what you've stated I leave you with this one word, "Depression".


I am feeling depressed at this very moment.  I've asked someone on this forum how they can live abroad in strange countries (as a journalist of all things!) and talk to any number of people from different cultures, learn different things on the fly, going through constant change... contrasting it with my difficulty in knowing the ropes of the same town I've lived in for 26 years, and my constant desire to stick by predictable routine.  And wondering how it could be possible that someone who supposedly has the same condition I have--AS--can be a journalist who travels around the world at will, alone and by themselves, with apparently no need for routine.  Just... how can it be?

The answer they gave me was they had a childhood where their Aspie traits were not tolerated ("beaten out of them"), evenutally thrown around into different foster homes, and then forced to pay their way alone.  This person told me they were fortunate to "not have had the chance to wallow in Aspie traits" and therefore got used to frequent changes in routine.  And so on.

My story:  The only thing I knew, back then--as a child--was that I had to have my way, I had to have my social oddities tolerated (and they were more accepted than punished), and I had to have my specific routines and interests and I had to be satisfied.  And I got my way.  My parents spoiled me.

Now if the opposite had occurred--if I had been through a much more chaotic childhood, roughed up, or moved around to different homes and locations--is it likely that I'd be a strong human being now, who can handle challenges as they come?

To think that having a nightmare of a childhood would make me less of an Aspie now, and a better human being instead, is a scary thought...


That is exactly why I think that state (public) schooling is preferable to home-schooling. That is why I believe, however ruthlessly, that what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. Even the most negative of experiences can result in wonderful outcomes. My parents were fairly abusive and my childhood largely unpleasant. I do not think that this is a good thing. I do believe that there should be a mediation, with neither brand of parenting allowed to ossify in the process. Tough love is exactly that: it is truer than relentless attention or forgiveness. We should not have to conform, but similarly we should not be left to suckle at the teet for too long. If you grow up without any sense of independence, struggle etc...then you are in a dangerous position. It's not a hopeless one, but the only way to overcome it is to immerse yourself in reality. Reality, whether NT or not, is not the subsumption into a personal and insular world. All human beings require -some- form of socialisation and participation.

Batman - re: the hard childhood thing.  I had a not so normal childhood witnessing domestic abuse and being scared of my father.  I was also considered a failure in Maths by him. He mentions it still.  He was wonderful at maths, a natural and tried teaching me and my brother... it wasn't the nice patient kind of teaching.  I have problems still with pressure situations and I think it might be to do with that.  Even in a friendly scrabble game, if people are watching me and I'm expected to add up something I really struggle and sometimes my mind even goes blank.

I also grew up in a home where there were often turtles in our bath, puppies in the laundry and chickens and other animals in our backyard. We lived in suburbia and I was teased in school because of how I smelt... I had no friends until Grade 4 when I met a nice nerdy girl.

So no, I don't think a bad childhood would make things better. In fact I think some of my self confidence problems come from back then. I still have problems with authority figures and my initial reaction when someone is putting me down is just to be submissive until I can get away, sometimes my mind just goes blank and doesn't think of the standing up for myself option until after the situation.

Batman55 Wrote:
It is amazing that still, no one on this site will acknowledge what these simple facts of mine might mean.  Lack of intelligence, dare I say it?

I guess everyone is afraid of bursting that artificial bubble of positivity.

Why can't people just see the facts and give me what I want.  I need to know I am defective...  and I will need outside parties to confirm it.

Is it too much to ask for such confirmation?


You already know why people won't agree with you... because it's not true.  Because although you may not be intelligent in certain types of intelligence, you are in fact intelligent in others.  I guess you've had a bad day and you don't feel good about yourself.  Seems you have a lot of those... maybe that's telling you something about the way you're living your life.  Maybe you don't get out of the house enough, even just for a walk through the park or a bikeride... maybe you are stuck in a rut that you need to get out of.  I don't get want you want from the people here.  You must know that nobody is going to tell you you're stupid, because it's simply not true.

O.K. that settles it. You're stupid then. Now, are you happy. I think it was in the movie "Forrest Gump" that Tom Hanks said, "stupid is as stupid does."

I reckon that I'm also stupid.

And that's all that I have to say about that.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Reference URL's