Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Diagnosed and Female Aspies
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Bella, how are you feeling having got your diagnosis? I imagine it must feel good to finally have some clarity. I feel pleased for you! Smile

Thanks for the collection of book titles. I have read "somebody somewhere" - I could very much relate to the writer of this book.

Ellen Wrote:
Can you give a url for "Beyond the Square"? My daughter might be interested at some point.

Here are my (maybe gross- I apologize ahead of time to any one offended! Big Grin) generalizations after raising an Aspie daughter, now 16, and having read some of the "female Aspie" literature:

Girls are harder to diagnose and frequently just get dxed as ADD (mine did)! I have also heard it takes 3 shrink visits til the correct dx is made most of the time!

Girls because of their hormonal, social upbringing and female brain are better at empathy than male Aspies.

For the above reasons maybe female Aspies don't usually lash out in middle school the way boys do. On OASIS and other Aspie sites young male aggression is a big problem in the schools (as a result of bullying or meltdowns or whatever).

According to Tony Attwood many female Aspies dread growing up, looking mature and stall the process as long as possible (my daughter in a nutshell). Many will have little girl voices also for the above reason (also Tony Attwood).

Female Aspies look younger than the general population imo. They are frequently pretty and have angelic faces (this from another Aspie female online, she calls them "Aspie angel faces") Wonder what the metaphysical reason is. First the metaphysical, then the physical I always say....

For many getting married and having children helped them to mature (anecdotal, based on online chats with other Aspie mothers, particularly on OASIS).

Aspie girls are frequently preyed upon by unscrupulous males. We seldom let Hope out of our sight for that reason! We tell her never to be alone with a male she doesn't know or trust.

People can now add their favorite gross generalizations. But there is always a grain of truth in generalizations, don't you think guys?

Ellen, I wanted to respond to your post. I have a daughter, she is not diagnosed, my son is.  My daughter is very shy, she has a degree in classics/history, she works as a cleaner.
She is able to achieve very well academically, both in sciences and languages. But she is very limited because of her shyness and communication difficulties. She suffers high anxiety when faced with social situations, new jobs etc.  Like your daughter she has the face of angel, she speaks in a soft childlike voice, and people always take her to be much younger than her years. She is my precious baby, still.
She loves animals and she would make a wonderful vet, but her communication and social problems prevent her from taking up this career option. Instead she has decided to focus on a career in IT. Disappointing in some ways.

My son required a diagnosis as when testosterone kicked in - he broke down, he was diagnosed with depression, anxiety, social phobia and then when I finally made contact with a doctor who could recognise aspergers, the correct and helpful diagnosis made.

Bella Wrote:
Interestingly though, even with the influence of that clinic, I've seen so many psychiatrists and medical professionals and it has never been suggested that I have Aspergers before.  


Same here--makes me wonder if I could get a DX, even if I tried.

Well, I am male, and I can say my Asperger's didn't begin to cause serious trouble for me until later adolescence (16-17 years old--around the same time it causes trouble for girls, it seems.)  I don't know if this means I don't have AS, or if I was lucky to somehow escape the horrific bullying I see so many others on here had.

I feel I was more ADHDish as a child (when ADHD should be naturally more apparent), and when that "overexcitement" subsided, the Asperger's became much more apparent.

I truly feel that many of us won't be so "obviously" Aspergian until life starts to become a "bit too much" for us to handle--then the AS problems start showing up in droves.  Which is true in my case--I managed to pass as an eccentric kid for a good while and had friends, but then... at a certain age... it all went rapidly downhill.

Any thoughts?
A thought I've had is that aspie men seem more feminine (in body language/posture) than other men while aspie women seem more masculine.

EnglishLulu Wrote:

Bella Wrote:
...I don't actually consider myself very good at dealing with emotions in others, so I don't know that that is correct.  I'm particularly bad at dealing with upset people.  My only method of helping is through advice.  It seems a lot of the time that people who are upset want sympathy mostly, which I don't do. ...

I relate to this.

I remember starting to read that book Men are from Mars and Women are from Venus a few years ago when it was all the rage, a few of my friends had copies and it was being passed around my social circle.

I got as far as Chapter 3, or whatever the chapter was...

It said something about if someone comes to you with a problem, men and women deal with that situation differently.  It said that if a woman complains to her partner about something that's happened or someone who's upset her, what she really wants is tea and sympathy, because that's what women offer in that scenario, and when her male partner doesn't deliver that, she gets even more upset and angry.

What men actually do is they don't offer tea and sympathy, they treat it as a problem that needs solving and they like to offer solutions.

I got that far and thought:  "Ohmigod!  I'm a bloke!"  (For the record, I'm female.)

I don't really do tea and sympathy either, I don't do empathy or emoting on behalf of other people, (although I do have quite volatile emotions myself if something goes wrong in my life), instead I think, okay, how do you solve this, what's the next step, what's the best thing to do now?  And then I tell people what to, how to solve their problem.


Me too, Big Grin which is why I started this thread

I have read half of those books.   For me, Liane's book was the closest to my situation.  Though I could not relate to Donna Williams at all, she did remind me of my ADHD/Aspie niece.  Ashley Stanford's book is the best one written by an NT, very very sympathetic to Aspies, as well as informative.

Congratulations on your diagnosis, Bella.  The book by the same name can be harrowing, but is excellent.  

The first person accounts are best, in my opinion.  Songs of the Gorilla Nation by Dawn Prince-Hughes is another really excellent account of growing up with undiagnosed AS.

An Aspie friend once told me I was the most man-like female he had ever known.

This is pathetic, but when I was a girl, the only REAL path in life was wife and mother, and I knew it, so I set about using my skills to achieve that goal.  This made me learn about emotions and having friends and getting help from friends regarding that single-minded pursuit of the boyfriend.  School was easy for me, so I could devote all of my time to this society-imposed special interest of mine, finding a husband.  Pathetic, but helpful maybe in the long run.  FWIW

ED2003 Wrote:
Congrats. Was it your first official DX then?

What is the price on closure these days?


Where I live in the USA it costs about two thousand dollars.  But that was a joke?  Closure, priceless and impossible.  Diagnosis, pricey.

Tong_Duurai Wrote:
Everytime I hear about children recently being diagnosed with asperger syndrome, its always boys. I also have noticed while most men with asperger syndrome were diagnosed in childhood or adolescence(Often a misdiagnosis with something else-at age 3 I was misdiagnosed with PDD-NOS in 1982 and it wasnt until 1991 that I got the aspergers diagnosis from a child psychiatrist), most women who are officially diagnosed were diagnosed in adulthood. Moreover, many aspie women say that they knew themselves that they were different but their abnormalities went unnoticed by adults. It almost seems like asperger syndrome affects women less severly, or at least in a less obvious way than it affects men.


I read your post - thought it was interesting and I it occured to me that you are right with your point about how in cases it affects women less severely or less obviously. My son has a diagnosis, but as he was growing up I could see he was just like me and my dad and brothers.
My son seemed to struggle more socially as he was growing up  perhaps because boys tend to play in groups, they don't seem to have one on one friendships to the same degree that girls do. My daughter and I are very quiet, socially, being female the world has different expectations of us.

To your first point - I don't think aspergers was included in the DSM IV until 1994 so this may explain why a correct diagnosis was not given. Also, three is young, I don't know that three year olds are into social play with their peers, it occurs to me that a diagnosis of aspergers at three years of age is not appropriate given this is such an early stage of social development.  Perhaps simply recognising a possible  autism spectrum disorder would be more fitting.

woman from mars Wrote:
In a nutshell, I think that it is expectations, lack of expectations & lack of awareness by the authorities which cause females to pass unnoticed through the system.
I believe that we will soon see a huge change in the statistics.


Not to be cynical, but why would these things change if it is the women who can get through unnoticed--with less pressure to conform--than the men?  Remember that Asperger's description in the DSM has a "the disturbance must be disabling" clause in it... not those words specifically (too lazy to look it up now) but something very much to that effect.

Bella Wrote:
I don't know that a diagnosis would be useful to everyone.  I have a friend who is undiagnosed, and I have yet to bring it up with him.  I think knowing about it would help him to overcome some of his social insecurities and confidence problems, but I don't think an actual diagnosis would help much.  I have two family members that I am educating about Autism as well.  I think unless there are major problems, then a diagnosis won't be helpful, but a self-diagnosis would be.


Well said, that's exactly the way I feel about this.  Basically you don't need an official diagnosis to confirm what you already know about yourself.

jewelie Wrote:
Maybe I'll start my own thread on this once it is a fait accompli, but as long as you are willing to share yours, Bella, I would just like to say that I have completed my initial interview and all five hours of testing, and am now waiting for the official word.  I AM concerned that my femaleness may stand in the way of a diagnosis, and will cross that bridge when I get to it.  It feels strange, but I am willing to FIGHT for a diagnosis!!  I've been studying this for two years now, and I am utterly convinced that I am an Aspie.  If the neuropsych doesn't agree, I want to educate him until he does!!!!!!!  Any other females have this reaction?


Same reaction here! I also have to fight with medical doctors who have prejudices about women and heart disease, women and Ankylosing Spondylitis (my other AS! Big Grin)

So why not fight with the neuropsychologists? :p

Thanks, Tigger, I didn't see your post before, somehow.  You have really been through the wringer, eh?  And in the case of physical problems, ignorance can KILL!  How many women have died because they didn't have the "right" ie. male symptoms of heart attack or what have you?  And though AS isn't fatal per se, we do have an elevated rate of suicide, so I think it is just about as serious to get a proper diagnosis.  I'm not sure of this, but I also think Aspies are more rash self-killers, ie. don't go through the same process as NTs, with warning signs of depression, etc, first, so it seems all the more important to FIGURE THIS OUT QUICK!

And it was a different thread, but I wanted to thank Tigger (if I hadn't done so already) for saying that her parents treat her as somewhat less than grown-up, despite the fact that she is a grandmother.  I suffer from what I call chronic youngest-itis, or so I thought, feeling as the youngest of five kids that I could never grow up in relation to them, they will always be older than me.  Now I know it is much, much more than that.  Thanks
Tigger, your doctors must have really been behind the times if they didn't think women could get heart disease and if they couldn't spot that you have ankylosing spondylitis. The number of women with heart disease has been going steadily upwards so it certainly something that should be investigated if a woman presents with jaw or chest pain and/or shortness of breath.

As for the ankylosing spondylitis, wouldn't X-Rays pick up that you have this condition?
Hi Bella, what made you decide to in for a diagnoses?

Why did you feel a diagnoses would be important to have?

Just asking.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6
Reference URL's