Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Homework Issues
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.

DW_a_mom Wrote:
My 10 year old son flips out most nights when he looks at his homework.  The volume or difficulty or some other aspect will freak him out.  And that is despite all the accommodations he is allowed (we can sign him out even if it has not all be finished based on time passed; he can dictate to me instead of writing himself, and so on).

Last night the issue was one specific language arts page that he thought was way too much, so I took a pen and blacked out half the sheet, hoping that once the visual volume was reduced he could process better that he did not have to do it all, just make an effort and get some practice.  But he STILL was all freaked out.  So I tried skipping that subject and doing one of his favorites.  But all he could think of was that with 4 different things to do, it was all too much.  He wasted over an hour upset about how much homework he had to do - when if he had been able to sit down for 50 minutes, he would have been signed out.  He knows it's a waste, we all do, but he can't get past the freak out.

Eventually, by fluke, he did go beyond the mental barrier last night, and managed to spend a solid hour getting work done, actually having a good time with it.  He had gotten so upset at my trying to help him with some math that apparently I was doing wrong (not on purpose, lol) that he stopped to show me how he had been taught to do it.  He loved doing that, explaining it to me.  As problems melted away by him showing me the process, everything became less scary to him.  But I can't use that every night, because it's a rare method that I don't have down pat, and he knows it.

My son and I talk about developing a process for going past the roadblock, but we don't have one yet.  He would really, really like one.

Has anyone experienced this and what processes have you found work to make the assignments seem less intimidating?





This is a complicated issue, imo. His accommodations seem well beyond and above what Hope got at that age, though.

Sarahjoke is right in that they give more homework than ever. But I've yet to see a graduating class outperform my generation in their SATs, but I digress.

Accommodations sometimes in certain classes become a two-edged sword- they help, then hinder as the child becomes used to getting the extra help when really he/she should be pushed a little. You have to take it on a case by case, class by class basis. Bottom line: Listen to what the teacher says re what the child needs. It's impossible to stay abreast of all the classes once they are in middle school so it's helpful if your child is in special educ. so that at least ONE teacher can keep track of it all. Hope was in special education starting in 5th grade so, again, one teacher was able to monitor her progress. Hope mainly used this class to do homework, not remedial work (her IQ is above average).

Case in point: Recently Hope's sophomore English teacher, knowing she is an Aspie and reluctant to read long novels, allowed her to write a book report on a volume of poems instead. Hope had three weeks to read the slim volume of Billy Collins' poems but ended up reading only two poems. I was furious. I.e., that is an example of an accommodation that backfired big time.

One of the best things we did was have a very experienced high school teacher teach her study skills last summer for about 5 sessions. I may have this woman re-teach HOpe these skills again next summer as well.  That, plus I constantly remind her to take small bites of all her assigned homework/study over the course of a week. I tell Hope is she just reviews at least once she will make good grades. I don't know where she is at the moment, but recently she was making nearly all Bs so it must be working (her best grades in two yrs.).

Also, this year it occurred to me she still didn't know how to organize and write reports so we are working on them together, also public presentations (she is taking public speaking). I try very hard to make sure the ideas are hers, but I am showing her how to write effective, flowing, professional-sounding prose. Few people in the workplace can write well (at least in the US) so hopefully this will pay off in the future.

I am really hoping next year I don't have to intervene at all- we'll see.

Hope this helps.

You are SO right Tigger... DD is drawing a picture of something she liked in the book. She is expected to draw all sorts of detail and color it properly. By detail the mean things doorknobs on doors and curtains on windows... She has to do two drawings... Its taken forever and she hates it. Sad  They had given her a worksheet with 3x5 inches to draw each drawing on... so I gave her some printer paper to draw each picture on... and it still takes forever... Sad

But we were having a hard time in the first place... sorry DW's mom, none of this helps!  But I have on more than one occasion not had her do her homework, some days it just isn't worth destroying her self concept for...
[quote=Tigger_the_Wing]
This thread has hit upon a 'pet peeve' Tongue

I believe that the US should go back to where homework for kids up to grade eight was illegal. If they hadn't been so paranoid about the threat from Russia during the Cold War it might still be illegal, and the rest of the world would not have followed into this ridiculous spiral of competitive education. Why the **** do we have international league-tables of educational outcomes?




--------------

True! Time magazine ran a long article on the homework nightmare about two years ago. AND STILL test scores aren't increasing in most schools!


"It seriously annoys me that parents are expected to be untrained, unpaid teachers of our kids; yet we then get stick for 'doing it wrong'."

Also true- I am the unpaid, though not untrained (I almost finished a teaching degree when Hope was young- an aborted career change), tutor when Hope is home and it exhausts me often. I find myself losing my temper if it is tough going or thorny in any way. Thank God I understand math a little, but I don't have the composure I used to. This is on top of a full-time job and a mother in assisted living whom I must visit 2x/week. My only saving grace is I have a cushy job....

But then I think the most recent research into methods shows a direct link between test scores and parental involvement and what they call "parental expectations of the student" even when controlling for race, income of parents....
oh i hate homework so much!! i go to a private school so i get TONS of it, and most of the time i leave it until the last minute (eg, the night before it's in, the morning it's in).

Tigger_the_Wing Wrote:
This thread has hit upon a 'pet peeve' Tongue

I believe that the US should go back to where homework for kids up to grade eight was illegal. If they hadn't been so paranoid about the threat from Russia during the Cold War it might still be illegal, and the rest of the world would not have followed into this ridiculous spiral of competitive education. Why the **** do we have international league-tables of educational outcomes?

My generation got homework as a matter of course in secondary school. Forty minutes per week per subject, divided into two twenty-minute sessions, rising to one hour in Third Form (year nine). This, apparently, was to 'prepare us for self-regulated study at University'.

When my oldest kids reached year six (the school year they turned eleven) they were assigned homework 'to prepare them for having to do it at Secondary School'. I strongly objected to the school, on the grounds that such reasoning could be used to drive the homework load down to pre-schoolers. Sadly, it appears that I was right. Sad

However, I am not the only one who thinks that the whole idea of homework is mad:

High school teacher Phil Lyons has become a heretic: He refuses to assign homework.

I have refused to bully my kids into doing homework. It only makes them less inclined to enjoy to schooling in the first place and sours my relationship with them. They are doing OK at school. Generally: either they have learned whatever they are supposed to in the first ten minutes of the class, and any further work on the subject is 'boring' Rolleyes; or they have failed to grasp it and are just going to be totally lost unless the subject is taught in a completely different manner, usually by me.

It seriously annoys me that parents are expected to be untrained, unpaid teachers of our kids; yet we then get stick for 'doing it wrong'.

Abandon homework. Return to the concept of childhood. The reason that so many of our kids are zoned-out in front of the telly/computer is because they are exhausted from the outrageous amount of time-wasting make-work they are sent home with from school.


40 minutes!:O

I get 4 HOURS per subject a week, litterally equates to a day spent in private study Sad

Pages: 1 2
Reference URL's