Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Kit Weintraub  again
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
By The Associated Press

The Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction opened an investigation Wednesday into a Monroe elementary school where parents said their special-needs children were locked inside a padded punishment room with the lights turned off.

In a report that aired Wednesday night on WKOW-TV in Madison, the station said a former teacher's aide at Abraham Lincoln Elementary School said that at least once, a 12-year-old child with Down's syndrome was locked inside a padded, 4-foot-by-8-foot room that did not have a door handle on the inside. The aide said she found the girl locked in the room, kicking and screaming in the dark.

"It's pretty spooky," the girl, identified as Katie, told the station.

The report did not name the aide.

The girl's mother, Holly Lelle, told the station her daughter sometimes can be aggressive and officials at the school asked her if they could place her in a time-out room. Lelle said she agreed, not realizing what the room would be like.

"We as parents have to be more aware," Lelle said. "I feel that we're not being told everything."

But Kit Weintraub, whose 10-year-old daughter, Emily, suffers from autism, defended the time-out room. She told WKOW-TV her daughter used to have 20 to 30 tantrums a day, and the room is a good last resort to calm a violent child. She said she doesn't believe the lights are turned off.

TheASman Wrote:

The girl's mother, Holly Lelle, told the station her daughter sometimes can be aggressive.


Can be aggressive???  What are we talking about. In my experience , nowadays even small amounts of agression is seen as worrisome -all out of proportion.

I you have too much aggression, yes that can be trouble. but define too much.   Also if your child doesnt have enough agression, then you are a raising a human foot stool.

We are talking about tantrums, they are not able to say "the girl with down's syndrome punched someone" and Kit isnt saying that her daughter was kicking or hitting out 20 times a day.
If a child of 12 in a regular school hit another child, they would never be locked into a padded cell, it would be called child abuse.

Amy Wrote:
We are talking about tantrums, they are not able to say "the girl with down's syndrome punched someone" and Kit isnt saying that her daughter was kicking or hitting out 20 times a day.
If a child of 12 in a regular school hit another child, they would never be locked into a padded cell, it would be called child abuse.

You sure it wouldn't just be called bullying?

Edit: Oh! You mean locking them up would be child abuse. Sorry about that.

Reference URL's