Aspies For Freedom

Full Version: Official vs self diagnosis
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
I'm gonna have to re-read your post later, as I'm in between classes, but for me, my university cannot give me anything other than extended exam time if I actually get a paper... For me, the validation is all I need/want. I guess it's different in different countries.
The extended time is the only thing I know about, although you can do your exams on a computer if you have learning disorders and such. The thing is, I don't think I need it. I can and have been freaked out by other students making noises as they write (pen on paper, etc,) people standing up and walking out for breaks with chaperones, etc, but I don't think I'd get a room all to my own.
I guess. Thank you Smile
Oh how I agree with you! Big Grin No need to say anything more.
Here are my thoughts:

Its not good for anyone to self-diagnose with anything.  There are too many common charecteristics between things as well as I have seen people self diagnose for these two reasons and both piss me off:

1: As an excuse for them wanting to be a jackass they just claim 'I have Aspergers'.  I use to work for one of these idiots.
2: Because its the latest and greatest fad to get attention from people.

If you self diagnose you dont have Aspergers you THINK YOU HAVE ASPERGERS.

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
Here are my thoughts:

Its not good for anyone to self-diagnose with anything.  There are too many common charecteristics between things as well as I have seen people self diagnose for these two reasons and both piss me off:

1: As an excuse for them wanting to be a jackass they just claim 'I have Aspergers'.  I use to work for one of these idiots.
2: Because its the latest and greatest fad to get attention from people.

If you self diagnose you dont have Aspergers you THINK YOU HAVE ASPERGERS.

You're right! I think I have Aspergers.But  you are wrong about the reason I self diagnosed.

1:I am no jack ***.I have no excuses.I want nothing in return.I don't 'act ' any certain way for any reason.

2:I get enough unwanted attention from people.Aspergers is not a fad to me.I have told only two people of me thinking I am Aspie.One had to agree the other laughed and thought it was my "strange sense of humor."

I self diagnosed mainly for my own peace of mind.I'm content with it.And you do not need to be angry at me for my choice.I am not hurting anyone by thinking I am Aspie.


Wrong, you didnt self diagnose - you just think you have Aspergers.  You are not qualified to diagnose anyone with anything - even a common cold.

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
Here are my thoughts:

Its not good for anyone to self-diagnose with anything.  There are too many common charecteristics between things as well as I have seen people self diagnose for these two reasons and both piss me off:

1: As an excuse for them wanting to be a jackass they just claim 'I have Aspergers'.  I use to work for one of these idiots.
2: Because its the latest and greatest fad to get attention from people.

If you self diagnose you dont have Aspergers you THINK YOU HAVE ASPERGERS.

You're right! I think I have Aspergers.But  you are wrong about the reason I self diagnosed.

1:I am no jack ***.I have no excuses.I want nothing in return.I don't 'act ' any certain way for any reason.

2:I get enough unwanted attention from people.Aspergers is not a fad to me.I have told only two people of me thinking I am Aspie.One had to agree the other laughed and thought it was my "strange sense of humor."

I self diagnosed mainly for my own peace of mind.I'm content with it.And you do not need to be angry at me for my choice.I am not hurting anyone by thinking I am Aspie.


Wrong, you didnt self diagnose - you just think you have Aspergers.  You are not qualified to diagnose anyone with anything - even a common cold.


Why are you here?


That seems kinda off topic, but if you must know feel free to start another thread.

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
Here are my thoughts:

Its not good for anyone to self-diagnose with anything.  There are too many common charecteristics between things as well as I have seen people self diagnose for these two reasons and both piss me off:

1: As an excuse for them wanting to be a jackass they just claim 'I have Aspergers'.  I use to work for one of these idiots.
2: Because its the latest and greatest fad to get attention from people.

If you self diagnose you dont have Aspergers you THINK YOU HAVE ASPERGERS.

You're right! I think I have Aspergers.But  you are wrong about the reason I self diagnosed.

1:I am no jack ***.I have no excuses.I want nothing in return.I don't 'act ' any certain way for any reason.

2:I get enough unwanted attention from people.Aspergers is not a fad to me.I have told only two people of me thinking I am Aspie.One had to agree the other laughed and thought it was my "strange sense of humor."

I self diagnosed mainly for my own peace of mind.I'm content with it.And you do not need to be angry at me for my choice.I am not hurting anyone by thinking I am Aspie.


Wrong, you didnt self diagnose - you just think you have Aspergers.  You are not qualified to diagnose anyone with anything - even a common cold.


Why are you here?


That seems kinda off topic, but if you must know feel free to start another thread.


I'm sorry if I went off topic.But my question was simple.Are you just here to put down people because your experience led you to believe some people would try to'fake' being an aspie?


Becuase I disagree with you and state my oppinion somehow gets connected to me putting you down.  Sounds like your taking this personal, can I ask why?  Maybe I hit the actual reason on the nose?

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
Here are my thoughts:

Its not good for anyone to self-diagnose with anything.  There are too many common charecteristics between things as well as I have seen people self diagnose for these two reasons and both piss me off:

1: As an excuse for them wanting to be a jackass they just claim 'I have Aspergers'.  I use to work for one of these idiots.
2: Because its the latest and greatest fad to get attention from people.

If you self diagnose you dont have Aspergers you THINK YOU HAVE ASPERGERS.

You're right! I think I have Aspergers.But  you are wrong about the reason I self diagnosed.

1:I am no jack ***.I have no excuses.I want nothing in return.I don't 'act ' any certain way for any reason.

2:I get enough unwanted attention from people.Aspergers is not a fad to me.I have told only two people of me thinking I am Aspie.One had to agree the other laughed and thought it was my "strange sense of humor."

I self diagnosed mainly for my own peace of mind.I'm content with it.And you do not need to be angry at me for my choice.I am not hurting anyone by thinking I am Aspie.


Wrong, you didnt self diagnose - you just think you have Aspergers.  You are not qualified to diagnose anyone with anything - even a common cold.


Why are you here?


That seems kinda off topic, but if you must know feel free to start another thread.


I'm sorry if I went off topic.But my question was simple.Are you just here to put down people because your experience led you to believe some people would try to'fake' being an aspie?


Becuase I disagree with you and state my oppinion somehow gets connected to me putting you down.  Sounds like your taking this personal, can I ask why?  Maybe I hit the actual reason on the nose?


We can disagree.I have no problem with that.Your snide remark about the common cold was unbecoming of you.


Well you arent qualified.  So you cant self diagnose something as complex as Aspergers Syndrome, because your not even qualiifed to diagnose a simple common cold.

Janet Wrote:
All that an official diagnostician can do is attest that s/he THINKS an individual has aspergers - there is no absolute "test."  Its just a description


That official diagnostician went to school for years to learn the different descriptions that are out there, they have plenty of expereince as well.  I have a friend going through medical school and the first thing they learn is don't diagnose yourself, the simple reason is self diagnosices are commonly innacurate do the brains ability to add things when there not there.  Plus in one way or another we all have some sort of symptons for tons of conditions out there.

Couldnt agree more Smile For some reason , my son who usually loves sledding didnt want to go. I believe its due to him finally feeling hot/cold differences. He obviously hates the cold now and I think that is why he didnt want to go sledding so I left my husband and older son sledding and we did something else. I would never force him to do anything.
He loves bowling which he is doing weekly with other children. He really enjoys it. He also enjoys basketball and baseball which he has played on teams for that. I sign him up for the social interactions and he loves to play so it works out.

DW_a_mom Wrote:

Batman55 Wrote:
I was never "forced" into extracurricular activities, as an aside... is that bad parenting you think, or just my style (because of extreme anxiety, I hated those things) ??


I personally don't think a parent should force anything "optional" on children.  Sell, sure.  Be a little pushy at times - maybe.  But force, no.

You have me a little worried about if I should be trying to follow my son's OT's rec that he always be involved in some sort of sport.  So far, he has played soccer every season and he tells me that he really likes it (even though it is obvious to everyone, including him, that he is the weakest player on the team).  It hasn't been without stress however, because he likes the games but hates practice.  We have asked him to think up something else he would be willing to enroll in for in-between, and for when soccer gets too competitive for him (we thought that would be this year, but he wanted to give it a go, and so far it's been OK).  He has expressed some interest in gymnastics, because he is very flexible, and it's an individual sport, and I do think he might enjoy it non-competitively.

It does get tough as a parent to know when to push a little, because you truly believe the child will get something positive from the activity that he just can't see right now, and when to listen to your child, because he is trying to tell you something real and important.

My son tried snow skiing for the first time this winter, and had a great time.  It was his decision to try, and my husband was very patient, allowing our son to go up and down a little mini hill instead of going up on the chair lift (exhausting for my husband, lol, all that trecking!), but it is so very important to allow a child to experience this sort of thing at his own pace.  I was really proud of my son.  All physical sports are difficult for him, but he was so proud of himself for doing this, and actually managing to succeed!  I hope that he never limits on the things he wants to do, assuming he WANTS to do them.

Batman55 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
That seems kinda off topic, but if you must know feel free to start another thread.


Don't feed the troll.  Explanation for the trolling:

TheZach is interested in feeling superior to those undiagnosed because of his official diagnosis.

Do not support this behavior--this goes for everyone.


I'm not trolling, Im just sick of people riding the bandwagon because they think its cool or they want attention.  You can't self diagnose yourself with any sort of nerological condition there way to complex.  You may think you have one but until you get a diagnosis you just think you have one, nothing more.

As for calling me a troll, grow up.  Just because I disagree with you does that mean I'm a troll?

woman from mars Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
Im just sick of people riding the bandwagon because they think its cool or they want attention.  You can't self diagnose yourself with any sort of nerological condition there way to complex.  You may think you have one but until you get a diagnosis you just think you have one, nothing more.


All of the ' self diagnosed ' people here who think that they have Asperger's could very easily have lied and said that they have a diagnosis, on an internet forum it would be difficult to disprove them.

We choose to be honest about ourselves, I have never seen anyone here who thought it was cool or sought attention because of it.

I have seen many who have found answers to questions that have puzzled them for years and I have also seen many people take comfort from the answers to questions that they have posed.

I have also seen many people who have received incorrect diagnoses for medical and psychological conditions from Doctors and Specialists, who as a consequence have received treatment which has made them worse, doctors aren't infallible any more than anyone else.


But having said this I fully accept that nothing is going to change your mind.


Because you cant self diagnose, you just think you have it.

Janet Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:

Chosen 1 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
Here are my thoughts:

Its not good for anyone to self-diagnose with anything.  There are too many common charecteristics between things as well as I have seen people self diagnose for these two reasons and both piss me off:

1: As an excuse for them wanting to be a jackass they just claim 'I have Aspergers'.  I use to work for one of these idiots.
2: Because its the latest and greatest fad to get attention from people.

If you self diagnose you dont have Aspergers you THINK YOU HAVE ASPERGERS.

You're right! I think I have Aspergers.But  you are wrong about the reason I self diagnosed.

1:I am no jack ***.I have no excuses.I want nothing in return.I don't 'act ' any certain way for any reason.

2:I get enough unwanted attention from people.Aspergers is not a fad to me.I have told only two people of me thinking I am Aspie.One had to agree the other laughed and thought it was my "strange sense of humor."

I self diagnosed mainly for my own peace of mind.I'm content with it.And you do not need to be angry at me for my choice.I am not hurting anyone by thinking I am Aspie.


Wrong, you didnt self diagnose - you just think you have Aspergers.  You are not qualified to diagnose anyone with anything - even a common cold.


This whole 'who can dx' thing is really dumb.  BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU HAVE AN *OFFICIAL* DX AND ARE FEELING PRETTY PROUD AND EXCLUSIVE

I (who is not qualified to dx) KNOW son has adhd.  the teachers (who are not qualified to dx) KNOW my son has it. the psych who is not qualified to dx it SUSPECTS my son has adhd b/c he asked parent & teachers (who KNOW) to answer questions.

The person *qualified to dx* it did not know my son, does not know much about adhd, looked at a letter (not my son) given her by the psych, and wrote the dx.  My son now has an *O.F.I.C.I.A.L.* diagnosis.  Boy are'nt we impressed (she said sarcastically)!

S.T.U.P.I.D.


No, whats S.T.U.P.I.D. as you put it is the fact that all these people decide they have something because they think they have it without seeking a medical oppinion.

Batman55 Wrote:

TheZach Wrote:
As for calling me a troll, grow up.  Just because I disagree with you does that mean I'm a troll?


No, but this kind of "self-DXers have no credibility" attitude is commonly considered trollish behavior, at least on AFF.  That's the perspective I'm coming from, here.


So now you speak for AFF?

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Reference URL's